Where Is China?

Via a map of the solar system

Had an interesting conversession on Resistance Is Fertile with the scholar Sheng Zhang. Broadly about where is China? Because on the other side of Asia, a genocide is going into its fourth winter, with the Jews and the Whites, in their cowardice, counting on biological warfare (starvation, disease, destruction of hospitals) to complete their dirty work. Of countries with official standing, only Iran has stood up. And they're being besieged, attacked, and even condemned at the UN for their courage. Where is revolutionary China during this great revolutionary moment?

The East Is Far

Zhang (who has his own opinions) analyzed Chinese foreign policy very simply saying "in terms of objective facts, West Asia is very far from China." I found this hilarious in that it's very true. Indeed, why should East Asia be involved in a war in West Asia and, moreso, which should North America, which is further by two! China is really the last believer in the UN ("the principle of the sovereign equality of all its Members" and a stubborn follower of geography.

China is often seen, from the White Empire, as a competitor to empire because in their house, every window is a mirror. Once a White man told me, 'well, all Empires are like this,' a version of the old Jewish saying, 'if I don't steal it, someone else will.' I had no ready retort because I hadn't thought about it that much, but now I have and 'no, they not.' Most empires were land based. They could be tested by the old Hindu running of the horse. It was only with the White Empire that intercontinental sea and then air based empires became a thing, ie as far as the crow flies and the seal can be bludgeoned. The most measurable measure of the difference between empires is distance, and how that distance is crossed. That's why West Asia is somehow close to North American and far from East Asia. Because they look at things competely differently.

Mao Is Dead

Zhang made another fascinating point saying, "I want to share a quote of Mao Zedong, he says 'today, our generation (meaning Mao Zedong's generation) is very radical, very revolutionary, but our sons will become reactionaries, our sons will become revisionists, eventually our grandsons will become revolutionaries again and they will struggle with our sons and defeat our sons and bring the country back to the right track."

This is fascinating because it applies out of China, to everywhere that tried to go socialist and was beaten/corrupted out of it. My grandfather was a Christian Communist and my father is a free marketer and now I'm something of an Islamist Communist in my own deranged way. The generational dynamics of socialism being tried, seemingly failing, and then becoming appealing again as the White Empire falls apart is global, not just Chinese. China is just better positioned to process the change is all.

Why? Because China has a strong communist party to mediate the class (and generational) struggles within its country and keep them on a track long-term. This is what I think people who don't read into it beyond The Economist (like me for many years) miss about 'autocratic' systems like communism, Islamic governance, or even monarchy. If you read Aristotle, he was entirely agnostic about which system, some suited some places and some suited others. What the Greeks called 'democracy' they wouldn't recognize in dysfunctional two or multi-party states that trend towards oligarchy, as Aristotle said about electoral democracy in general. Democracy would mean rule by the majority, which is what China has, but only because the communist party has its thumb on the scales!

People that don't read anything from China directly don't understand how wild, varied, and often infuriating the debate from inside China is. There is much more debate and much freer speech in China with clearly marked guard-rails about internal policy. About foreign affairs they're quite laissez-faire because the PRC is not an Empire and does not care much. The watchword is internal stability, not destabilizing the world.

In China, people can (and do) support Ukraine or Russia, 'Israel' or Palestine, in a way that people within the White Empire are simply not familiar with. In the heart of Whiteness, you can literally lose your job, speech rights, freedom, or life for the wrong position on ostensibly 'foreign' subjects, like who are we genociding or human sacrificing this week in the Cable TV Colosseum. This restriction on ostensibly 'foreign' speech shows that such people live in an empire and not whatever false flag they see flying at sports matches. But they still crow about their 'freedom' relative to China, but freedom to what? Hate exactly who you're supposed to, and no one you should? As Zhang said,

In the West there's no real debate, if you go to them and say 'Oh, I think Putin has some reason to do this,' you get cancelled. You're a Putin apologist, a Russian spy or whatever. In China actually you can say things like 'I support Ukraine'. I have seen so many people in Beijing doing that. There's liberal pro-American journalists or academics they often say things [like] 'we support Ukraine, we support 'Israel', 'Israel' is the civilized country of the Middle East.' And they do that. The government never shuts them down. There is a very vibrant debate in the Chinese society and in this debate you can clearly see that there is a very clear generational and class difference.

As Zhang goes on, the younger generations is (as Mao predicted) are more Maoist ie internationalist while their parents are more Dengist and isolationist (for lack of a better term). And the class breakdown is that petty bourgeoisusssser like academics, journalists, and lawyers are very pro United States, even when the US has said their own country is next on the cannibal's plate. Thus, thank God for the CPC, which has kept the Empire from exploiting the class division that exists everywhere to divide and conquer another state. As Zhang said, "It's because the Chinese Communist system is the system that prevents those occupations [the petty b] from hijacking politics and making tons of money." The party line is still close to the party line, ie closer to Russia, Iran, and the Resistance, though not a part of it. It is really as Mao said, and it's largely due to his radical foresight (including, regrettably, the Cultural Revolution) that China is able to function today.

What made Mao different was that he saw way further ahead and had the strength to drag a billion people forward with him. But now those billion people are forward, and they understandably have more to lose.

Long Live Mao

Deng Xiaoping, who succeeded Mao, said, "Keep a cool head and maintain a low profile. Never take the lead – but aim to do something big." This broadly happened, and you can say that China is in the enviable position the United States was post World War II, with fighting all around them and them supplying everyone, including the ungrateful US and Greater 'Israel' (Saudi, UAE, etc). But this is, of course, not the analogy the US is aiming for.

Today the US openly threatens China. In fact, many view their destruction across Asia and of the global economy as targeting China, albeit indirectly. The oil in West Asia was going east, ie to China, and the buyers of Chinese goods won't be buying so much when the global economy craters, as it already has for many. Hence China is moreso in the analagous position of the USSR in World War II, in an unstable and patently illogical truce with a carnivorous power that simply hasn't got to them yet. As Zhang said about the reluctance to fight fascism then or now, until it was already chomping down,

We're making the same mistake, it's going to be very difficult for China to consciously recognize this, but I have faith in Americans. The Americans will force China to realize this. They pushed Putin and they pushed Khamenei to realize this, they're eventually going to push China as well. (41:00)

People are getting, slowly, what Mao was saying, and in China, unlike the White Empire, what people think and talk about actually makes a difference. Though as with the politically diverse people of Iran, Russia, or every country, they won't do something about it until something is done to them. So that's broadly, where China is. In China.

It was a good conversation, listen here and subscribe to the pod.