
Sketch of James Bond commissioned by Ian Fleming. Via Wikipedia
Star Movies is showing a Bond marathon in anticipation of Casino Royale. I have been watching it because I feel like it gives some cumulative structure to my joblessness. The riffs each Bond actor has to play are very similar, and it’s an interesting template to compare them. My personal favorite might be a bit off, but it’s the one I grew up with, the rest being archival footage. I am sure of the worst bond, and the bottom two both totally suck IMHO. All in all, however, I think the Bond format is simple yet compelling and always entertaining. It’s not the modern darkness of Bourne Identity or 24, but something cleaner and lighter on the palate. It’s not inspiring film-making or anything, but it’s usually a good time.
5. George Lazenby
Worst. Bond. Ever. He hits women, halfway pays for sex and – worst of all – falls in love, goes on long horse rides and gets married. On Her Majesty’s Secret Service is hands down the worst Bond movie, and one of the worst movies I’ve seen. It takes all the twists of the book, which makes for an overcomplicated movie. Also, this Bond’s misogyny and violence are unleavened by humor, making him almost contemptible. What I will say is that Lazenby was the most athletic Bond and the best natural fighter.
4. Timothy Dalton
I actually haven’t watched his Bond films all the way through cause they kinda bore me. What I remember was him being more dirty than most and being rescued by the Bond girl. The movies were very 80s to me, the teenage years of the century, an awkward outgrowth of the hip 60s and 70s that still hasn’t resolved itself. As such, the fashion is bad, the violence gratuitous, and the Bond neither strong nor charismatic enough to carry the films.
3. Roger Moore
I actually like Roger Moore because he’s funny. I’ve never seen The Saint so that never affected my perception. He seems a bit older (and blonder) than my mental Bond, but he was good with the wisecracks. He’s the longest running Bond (12 years) and has done more to take him from the character in the novel to its own entity. In fact, I think his movies were the first to not take titles or storylines from the books. Apparently Lazenby’s Majesty’s Service was the most faithful to the book, but I don’t think that’s a virtue in a movie.
2. Sean Connery
This is most people’s first, but I guess I’ve it late and it doesn’t have the same impact for me. He’s definitely the most handsome and agile of the Bond’s, and prolly dresses the best. He also mixes humor and confidence well without being a boor like Lazenby or nonchalant like Moore. However, I never felt that any of his films were fabulous, and I do find that technology has given a huge boost to my final pick,
1. Pierce Brosnan
This is sacrilege, but I think Brosnan acts and looks the part of Bond better than anyone, especially facially. Also, he has been greatly aided by state-of-the-art special effects and in-movie technology, delivered with sardonic wit. However, Die Another Day may actually be a worse movie that Her Majesty’s as it doesn’t even have kitsch value. The dialogue and plotting in that movie were unfathomably bad, but that still doesn’t take away from the best movie in the Bond series – Goldeneye. Goldeneye is a captivating story with a tank running through St. Petersburg and two compelling female co-stars. Well, maybe not the best, but it’s certainly the one that stands out as a movie and not just a Bond film, to me.
Ideal Bond
This is someone else’s suggestion (who I forgot) but I think Robbie Williams would be a great Bond. Or, a bit younger George Clooney (and Lazenby was Australian so I don’t see how being American matters. Some other picks would be Jude Law and, or course, Ranjan Ramanayake.
However, the producers have neglected the Sri Lankan Stallion and chosen Daniel Craig, who looks like a battered boxer to me, but he was a good actor in Munich. I dunno if he can pull it off, but he’s not a bad actor and Casino Royale looks like a cool backstory kinda movie. We shall see. I think it’s out in a couple weeks.
Agree. I liked Brosnan too. Strangely, none of the ladies i spoke to like him. They all preferred Connery.
Would have loved to see how Hugh Jackman played bond though..
i think Brosnan made a good Bond altho he’s a bit skinny and small.. casino royale is showing this Thursday.. in the UK that is..
Roger Moore played the role better than any other (I saw Saint before I saw a Bond movie so could be bit biased)
I always thought he fitted the “profile” much better. Sean Connery never made an impression in my mind as James Bond, even after seeing a few of the old movies in Star (mind you the first Connery Bond movie I saw was ‘Never Say ever Again’, he must have been at least 55-60 years old then, definitely too old to be James Bond), although he is always brilliant in any other character. I can understand why ladies would like him better though.
Brosnan has done a very good job in playing the role, and he has stepped out at the right time.
Connery was the only Bond personally picked by Fleming, so to say moore fitted the profile better is questionable, Niroshan. And the first Bond you see will always be THE Bond. Just like Keaton will always be Batman.
Indi, most of your evaluations about the Bond actors are more about the script and the direction rather than the actor.
Lazenby wasn’t the worst Bond; ‘On Her Majesty’s Secret Service’ was just the worst Bond movie ever. It bombed, and so therefore did poor ol’ George. He was also a boxer who moved into movies, so that’s why the fighting came naturally.
Moore, I personally think, was the worst Bond. He just rehashed his Saint character. Basically the same thing he’s done in every one of his movies, from ‘The switch’ to ‘The Wild Geese’.
Think Dalton was better than Moore, since the role is that of a killer not a playboy. Dalton was just too dark and moody. Read boring.
Connery and Brosnan are certainly tied for the top slot. Imagine Connery at his peak starring in a modern flick like ‘Golden Eye’.
I dunno who suggested Robbie Williams & Jude Law (I know a couple of ladies have with the latter), but if you want a short guy who looks like a chimp, or a metrosexual mannequin, then they’re perfect. Clooney would’ve been great a few years ago, or even Travolta as he looked in ‘Broken Arrow’.
But Clive Owen would have been the perfect Bond (pity he turned it down).
Agreed. Clive Owen would have been the best. He was virtually a Bond character in the BMW films, and the character fitted him like a glove.
The best Bond that never was?