The Tragic Assault On Diplomats In Libya And Egypt


I was very sad to hear and shocked to see (careful) that the US Ambassador to Libya has been killed by a mob and that the US embassies in Libya and Egypt have been attacked. As Christopher Hitchens said in this video, diplomatic privilege is one of the most important advantages of civilization and to see it attacked so brutally is just a human tragedy.

Any country needs to be able to maintain embassies and diplomats. This is how we get conversation between nations and how civilization stitches itself together. To violate that is just an affront to civilization as a whole. There’s nothing political to this at all. And, to top it off, the murder of Chris Stevens is just heartbreaking. You can see his body being carried (by a Libyan civilian) in the link above and I can’t get the image out of my head. I mean, that you can beat a man and take the life out of him, that we’re all frail human beings with bodies and hearts and families and blood. It’s just horrifying and wrong. To beat and crush any of these frail vessels over nations or ignorance, it’s just a human shame.

I mean, my God. We were just talking about cartoons and how community outrage and offense can lead to the idea that violence is somehow justified. The idea that there’s this offense that justifies any response just isn’t true and should never been indulged. Worked with I guess, but the idea that any action by any human being justifies violence by another is just never true.

These attacks were ostensibly a response to a video offensive to the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) posted on the Internet. The video btw, is so amateurish and insanely dumb that it’s offensive mainly to itself. The depiction of Muhammad is actually pretty horrific, weirdly insulting, sexualized, and so, so dumb. Ignorant and really really disrespectful. And really weird. It’s white people dressed up as Arabs in front of a green screen, talking like valley girls.

Still, this violence does not reflect the Muslims I know or the Islam, the lived Islam, that they have shown me. I agree with this quote by Mohamed El Dahshan.

There is no virtue in displaying lethal outrage (as in Benghazi) whenever anyone throws a feeble punch at Islam and Muslims. Doing so is only a display of weakness, a fear that our religion cannot withstand even the silliest of skits. This idea is insulting in itself. Bring on the insults, I say — bring on the hatred, the mockery, the piques, the spitballs. The amateur films, the Danish cartoons, the Geert Wilders, and the like. There is little harm than can befall Islam as a faith. It has withstood, over the past fourteen centuries, infinitely worse attacks, yet it has neither weakened nor vanished.

Honestly, whatever you think about American foreign policy, this has nothing to do with that. This is just a sad sad day. Human bodies were crushed and human diplomacy was violated. It’s just a sad, tragic day, for everyone involved.

RSS feed | Trackback URI

7 Comments »

Maf
2012-09-13 18:27:26
 
tastyjujubes
2012-09-15 16:04:15

To be honest, when Islam is discussed I think there is an elephant in the room and that is the Prophet Muhammad. The man may have founded Islam, but he can hardly be called an example to follow going by what is the Quran and Hadiths. The man led wars, killed people, had many wives, had sexual relations with an underage girl, supported slavery etc. These may be uncomfortable facts to consider but they need to be considered and not pushed under the carpet.

I can see how the video is deeply insulting to those of the Islamic faith. It should not have been released and I wonder what they exact motives of the producer are. But certain sections of the Quran itself are quite deeply insulting towards non-Muslims.

USA
2012-09-19 20:25:48

“Islam has withstood, over the past fourteen centuries, infinitely worse attacks, yet it has neither weakened nor vanished” Why?
isn’t this the time to learn real Islam and about Prophet Muhammed, Instead of trying to understand through hatred media (Films, Cartoon, Websites, western news channels…etc)..?

tastyjujubes
2012-09-20 00:08:42

Have you read the Quran? If you haven’t, I suggest you do. Although I suppose when it comes to murder, hatred and senseless violence the Old Testamenttrumps the Quran. And also, do you accept the Hadiths as an integral part of Islam?

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
 
 
2012-09-17 04:59:56

Time to move to Antartica…

http://tinyurl.com/9k6ar7m

shammi
2012-09-17 21:25:02

Is that where the dodo’s gone? :(

 
 
2012-09-22 20:40:11

[...] benign Benghazis After Libyan mobs brutally and shamefully killed the US Ambassador, counter-mobs are now mobbing the original mob. Which is kinda, well it feels somehow positive, but [...]

 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

email indi AT indi.ca.


Recent Comments


Monolithic Islam (2)

tastyjujubes: A Muslim is someone who follows Islam, yes? Islam teaches that all non-Muslims will burn in hell for eternity yes? So if one were to say that Muslims believe that all non-Muslims will burn in hell for eternity, would that be wrong?

Gorogoro: Yes there is diversity, but unfortunately the extremists and the fundamentalists among the Muslims seem to have a free reign. You can certainly make some generalizations when the ideology being followed is one and the same and is based...

40 Under 40 (1)

sharanga: Congratulations !

Anti-Social Marketing (Nibras Bawa) (19)

David Blacker: Who cares, man? you’re still moaning on about a fight you lost months ago. It’s like the kid who gets his ass kicked then talk big later. You lost, you ran away like a whiney ponneya, and now you’re actually...

sharanga: A more accurate description would be I had my penis up your because you were refusing to answer a simple question. Now the fact that you thought I was not just Heshan, but also meechum just shows that you are stupid, and therefore your...

David Blacker: Come, come, you ran away from that debate with tail tucked in your panties. Too late late to be a hero now, man. Why don’t you make up a few more “facts 221;? As for you being Heshan, etc, well, can you blame me? All...

Chi Chi Hits The Scene, And A Referee (5)

sack: Indiz post about Gotabhaya had much more comments. http://indi.ca/ 2012/07/gotas-p uppy-hate/

Liberal One: He he, the article with the least number of comments out of Indi’s recent ones. Looks like no body wants to put their lives at risk by commenting on the wrong article. I’m off as well.

max: Every family should have a Fredo

The Arrest Of Azath Salley (21)

tastyjujubes: Well Nafi, why are you worried about the Jews and Israel and the US and western culture? Simple fact is that a lot of people do not want Sri Lanka to be an Islamic country or another Saudi Arabia. Sri Lanka has a long tradition of...

Monolithic Islam

Mohsin Hamid, author of How To Get Filthy Rich In Rising Asia, has a nice op-ed in the Guardian. Money quote for me was ‘Individuals are undeniably real. Groups, on the other hand, are assertions of opinion’. If you go buy news reports Muslims or Jews or Sri Lankans or any number of groups can appear monolithic and uniform. When you meet people, however, you find that they’re not. If you meet enough people you hopefully become aware of that tendency and judge people less by group identity in advance. Muslims, however, are quite publicly tarred with the same brush these days, and it really isn’t fair. Or accurate.

40 Under 40

I’m happy to be featured in Echelon magazine’s 40 Under 40 feature, profiling young people who contribute to the economy in some way, mainly in business but also in terms of innovation and thought leadership. It’s an interesting article not just in that I’m in it (mainly for work on indi.ca and Kottu but also YAMU) but also in that the magazine takes a bit of a critical stance. It’s worth reading the editorial (which I can only find in print) where they describe that only a few women are included and that all of the 40 are from middle to upper middle class backgrounds.

Chi Chi Hits The Scene, And A Referee

I won’t add too much commentary, but just read I guess. The youngest Rajapaksa, Rohitha (Chi Chi) has given an amazing interview to the Daily Mirror Life section, which is well worth a read. In other news, he also recently slapped a referee around in full public view at a rugby match. At least it seems that his elder brother restrained him.

Anti-Social Marketing (Nibras Bawa)

In 2009 this strange character appeared on the Sri Lankan Internet scene, getting angry, flaming, trolling whatever. Then he started naming anonymous bloggers, posting comments as people’s kids, nasty stuff, for which I removed him from Kottu. He also published some plagiarized stuff on Groundviews. He flamed out a bit more then disappeared. Until now. Now he’s back hosting a rather expensive social media event in Colombo, which is a bit ironic, seeing as he was known for being the most anti-social person the blogosphere had seen at the time.