Tourists Arrested For Mocking Buddha (Statue)
Buddha statue at Embekka Devale (not sure if it’s the same one) by igz.
Three French tourists just got a suspended sentence for taking mocking photographs with a Buddha statue at Embekka Devale. They took their photos to be printed in Galle and the studio handed them in to the police. I’m not sure what exactly they were charged under, but they received a suspended sentence and their passports and cameras were returned.
As the UK issues a travel warning and Sri Lanka generally embarrasses itself, one might file this in that category. I mean, what were the tourists doing that was so bad? But I don’t think so. What they were doing was bad. I’ve gone to many places of worship and I’m always scrupulous about following whatever rules I’m supposed to follow. One unwritten rule is don’t mock the place or act the fool. Which is what these tourists were doing, and they got off with a scare and a Rs. 1,500 fine.
As a Buddhist do I personally venerate statues or symbols? Not really, but I don’t disrespect them either. I must admit that one time, when I first returned to Sri Lanka, I made a bit of a faux pas. I was at a temple in Kandy for a few days of meditation, by myself, not with a group. On poya some locals came over and were worshiping. I had been meditating in the room so I just got up and hung out. A few girls came by with trays of flowers. Being fresh off the boat, I took one of each. After a while I was like, ‘how can I hold all these flowers’. It turns out I was just supposed to put my hands out and bless the flowers, not take them. I’ve also tried to drink the ceremonial glasses of water at rural weddings. Anyways.
There’s levels of cultural misunderstanding which can be understood, but kissing and posing with a Buddha statue in a temple is ungood. At Buddha Bar, whatever I guess, it’s not here, but there are certain standards. My only issue is that I’m not sure where or how this falls under Sri Lankan law. Except, being an ostensibly Buddhist state, I suppose it does. I personally think a stern talking to would do, but in this case I don’t think the punishment is entirely out of line with the crime.


Mohsin Hamid, author of How To Get Filthy Rich In Rising Asia, has a nice
I’m happy to be featured in Echelon magazine’s 40 Under 40 feature, profiling young people who contribute to the economy in some way, mainly in business but also in terms of innovation and thought leadership. It’s an interesting article not just in that I’m in it (mainly for work on indi.ca and
I won’t add too much commentary, but just read I guess. The youngest Rajapaksa, Rohitha (Chi Chi) has given an amazing interview to the
In 2009 this strange character appeared on the Sri Lankan Internet scene, getting angry, flaming, trolling whatever. Then he started naming anonymous bloggers, posting comments as people’s kids, nasty stuff, for which I removed him from 
Look at how these disgusting people have taken the photograps:
http://lankacnews.com/sinhala/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/ambakke-farcne-n.jpg
This is basically Western Civilization. Making fun other others is their pastime.
In Thailand you have to be VERY careful not to mock, insult or in anyway disparage the king or the royal family. Even the guidebooks mention this quite specifically. The guidebooks also explain expected behaviour at religious places.
I think there are warnings already.
May be not in official government websites but remember reading them in some travelers sites.
Anyways same thing would have happened if try to do a similar act in a kovil, church or a Mosque.
I don’t remember seeing any “warnings” when it comes to Sri Lanka. The guidebooks I mentioned are ones that are produced by the Thais and given free of charge to tourists at various hotels/tourist attractions. Maybe Sri Lanka needs to do the same? Although its probably commonsense that you don’t kiss a religious statue on the mouth at a temple/church, or any other religious place for that matter.
The above are not comments made by me. It seems like someone has stolen my name (identity) and is writing under that name illegally. Writers must attempt to either write under their own name or a pseudonym but not steal others’ identities.
I can’t tell who the real Lasantha Pethiyagoda is, but I removed prior comments under than name
I agree, a stern warning would have been good enough for the French tourists to realise what they were up to is not acceptable in this part of the world. Dragging them to police and courts and is a bit over the top.
Only if our police and courts were equally quick to give sentences to the monks who destroyed part of the mosque in Dambulla or the monk that stole the Ganesh statue from the Kovil in Panama.
We should treat places of religious significance as if they were court-houses. If it’s something important, like expressing a political opinion, it should be allowed. So Pussy Riot should be allowed to sing against Putin in cathedrals. On the other hand, people should not be allowed to be obnoxious for the sake of being obnoxious, so the French tourists were out of line, so they deserve, well, a fine. I don’t recommend putting people into jail for this sort of thing. But I suppose, if those tourists were locals, that’s exactly what would’ve happened, and they’d be beaten a little for good measure.
This case couldn’t be better timed. Rather than the GoSL making stupid complaints about the British travel advisory, they should quote from it:
“You are subject to local laws in Sri Lanka and violating them may result in a jail sentence.
There are severe penalties for all drug offences and crimes related to the abuse of children. In some circumstances detainees can be held without charge, indefinitely and convicted offenders may face lengthy jail sentences.
Same-sex relations are illegal.
Nude or topless sunbathing is generally not allowed.
Although Sri Lankan attitudes to informal European styles of dress are generally relaxed, women travelling alone, especially after dark, may be made to feel uncomfortable if not dressed modestly. You should consider religious and other sensibilities. Do not enter a Buddhist temple wearing headgear or with bare legs or shoulders and always remove footwear. You should avoid posing for photographs standing in front of a statue of Buddha.”
In fact, the British advisory is actually reasonable and accurate.
As for this case? I say that if breakage disrespectful at a members’ club, you get a warning, thrown out and maybe fined. Churches/temples/mosques are members’ clubs, so fair enough. Any more than that is state-sponsored over-protection, which it’s the people’s right to demand if they want to be bastards. Just don’t expect the foreign money if foreigners aren’t given a fair warning.
Silly peck on the the Buddha statue cheek should not amount to such brutal punishment for the French Tourists.
These foreigners do not hate Buddhism !! They are our guests and they made silly mistake .
Making a mountain out of a small thing, wasting time of courts when courts have very serious jobs to do, inciting words of hatred over a kiss, thinking Buddha Idols can be insulted by ignorant actions, nothing of this sounds anything close to Buddhism taught by Lord Buddha.
Buddha DOES NOT mind any girl kissing one of the idols made for him and if he did he wouldn’t be Buddha!!
Yes, a fine of something like $15 is such a brutal punishment. Let’s get the Christians kissing and making out with a statue of Jesus first. I’m sure Jesus wouldn’t mind.
Soto
It 1,500 rupees ($11) each, actually !!
The French Tourists were arrested, imprisoned and sentenced to 6 months imprison by the Sri Lanka judge !!!
This just too much !!!
I dont think, these French visitors are appreciating that kind of “hospitality”
Have you ever been arrested and put in Sri Lanka jail ??
At the end of the day, all they received was a $15 fine. Nothing more. So brutal it hurts.
Soto you are pitiless !!!
The poor French girl is scared for life by the brutal Sri Lanka jail …
I couldn’t care less to be honest.
Soto
I get it… You dont care about Sri Lanka Tourism, the money it gets or world wide opinion about Sri Lanka??
Yes you got it right. Problem?
Soto
Ahh …how sad..
BTW
What a selfish brat you are… spitting on Lord Buddha teachings
The only one spitting on Lord Buddha’s teachings is you.
Soto
I strongly advise you to look the Lord Buddha teachings again and at the same time refresh your English Language too
It is I who would advise you to look at Lord Buddha’s teachings again and at the same time learn to use proper English grammar and spelling.
Soto
It is not the quantum of the fine, it is the fear and uncertainty caused by the police arresting and holding them in detention. How would you have reacted if it had happened to you on a visit to some foreign land, because you unwittingly broke some rule that you did not understand?
Tourism was the only industry that had any hope, even that was only doing as half as well they said it was, they are busy digging their own grave.
Dont think there will be too many takers for these:
http://www.lbo.lk/fullstory.php?nid=1513921377
Jack Point
If you visit a country, it’s best you learn something about it before you go. Have a look at the rules and regulations. Perhaps learn a little bit of the culture and the language. Which areas are safe and which areas are not. Maybe get some injections and take some malaria pills. It’s not anyone else’s problem if you go to a foreign country and get into trouble by doing stupid things. At the end of the day all these tourists got was a $15 fine. I’m sure their bank must be broken.
Singapore and Malaysia have executed tourists for carrying drugs.
Singapore has caned tourists for vandalism.
But tourism is booming in those two countries.
So you will understand if I take your doomsday ramblings with a pinch of salt.
Malaria, drugs – these are standard problems.
Taking photographs -??? Is that a problem in Malaysia or Singapore?
Was a tourist caned for vandalism in Singapore? Not to my knowledge. A resident was, I believe. Doomeday scenario- its already happening. Just do a google search and see how many news agencies and websites have carried the story.
Not to mention FB. Can you imagine what their status updates might have looked like and how widely they may have been shared?
Singapore to cane Swiss man for graffiti terrorism
Prosecutors said Fricker and Alexander became friends after meeting in Australia in 1997 and the vandalism took place when Alexander visited Singapore as a tourist.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/7853690/Singapore-to-cane-Swiss-man-for-graffiti-terrorism.html
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Swiss jailed 10 years for insulting Thai royalty
Oliver Rudolf Jufer, 57, was initially sentenced to 20 years for five acts of lese-majeste, but the judge reduced the term to take into account Jufer’s guilty plea earlier this month.
http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/4e77b830-ddcd-11db-afa7-000b5df10621.html
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
It’s not a bad thing if many websites have carried the story. Potential tourists will learn about about what not to do in Sri Lanka. Moreover, they will be more sensitive when they visit other Buddhist majority countries like Thailand, Burma, Cambodia, Laos or other Hindu majority countries like India and Nepal (since most westerners can’t differentiate between Buddhism, Hinduism, Jainism etc).
There is a difference between an act of vandalism and taking a photograph. Both examples are of that.
In any case the Thai Lese Majeste laws are hardly examples to be followed, although we seem to moving in that direction.
What may be vandalism for one may not be vandalism to another. Judging by the responses in the newspapers and what I’ve personally heard, it’s clear that many people in Sri Lanka do not approve of what the French tourists did. They received a $15 fine for it. If that seems excessive to you then so be it. Others – including me – do not share your opinion.
It does not matter whether you approve or disapprove of Thai lese majeste laws. If you go to Thailand it is incumbent on you to be aware of it and behave accordingly. Now, hopefully, tourists who visit Sri Lanka will behave in an appropriate manner, or take steps not to behave in an offensive manner when it comes to Buddha statues.
The law is an ass. Soto is basically an arse. This isn’t about whether the law should be enforced, but about whether such stupid laws are necessary in an era when the courts are backlogged with actual land disputes, murders, rapes, etc. It’s a need for perspective, not anal retentiveness.
An arse would be someone who takes to personal insults to get a point across. I don’t see how a $15 fine could be seen as excessive.
If I had gone to church and spunked on a statue of mother mary, would that be ok then? Where do you draw the line. Saliva is ok but spunk is not ? Disrespect of another culture or religion is just that. The intent is either there or not. These people obviously do not respect Sri Lanka or its culture. A stern talking to would serve no purpose. Who cares about a lecture from a bunch of “primitive” idol worshippers. Justice was done here. End of. Learn to respect others or get your ass kicked.
Such
Are the French Tourists spunked on a Buddha statue ????
Never heard of this have you?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piss_Christ
Its come under attack by some fanatics of late, but then no ones takes any notice of a fanatic.
OMG !! Rajapaksa Government playing skilfully a “Victim ” Card !!! Government spokesman said that the French Tourists would… ” would have taken the pictures abroad, published them and gloated at them.. ?????” He is painting this innocent blunder into the War against Buddhism !!!!!!
BTW why would French Tourists publish their family holiday pics ???
Rajapaksa Regime is making the mountain out the molehill !!!
I think, it is a good way to scare off the tourists and irresponsible way to run the tourist industry.
http://news.yahoo.com/sri-lanka-condemns-buddha-kissing-french-tourists-131907883.html?_esi=1
Rajapaksa government is becoming more radical then the Taliban
And you are getting pretty good at posting using different names.
Sumudu Weeratunge = Shramantha Weeratunge = Dayan Kurukulasuriya = Lasantha Pethiyagoda = Semini Iddamalgoda = Dhanapala Udawatte
Keep up the good work.
What a silly Soto!!
Conspiracy around every corner… You should visit a doctor and soon…
So what new name are you going come up with next?
Don’t like it when others do it, Soto?
What ???
Me…learning proper this and that , when you don’t have a proper heart in your body… just a piece of cold ice. Yes you are a “Proper Patriot” and superb Ruthless Rajapaksa bootlicker !!
Yes, that’s right you should look at Lord Buddha’s teachings again and at the same time learn to use proper English grammar and spelling.
Soto, the silly goat … blindly following the Mass Murderer Rajapaksa Death March into abyss
You don’t seem to be following Lord Buddha’s teachings with your hate speech. Please go and look at Lord Buddha’s teachings again.
Where in the Buddha’s teachings you find that the mass murder of the innocent is allowed ?
You are abusing people and using hate speech. Don’t spit on Lord Buddha’s teachings please.
The killing the innocent people is not part of Buddha’s teachings
Please stop abusing people and using hate speech. You should be ashamed of yourself for spitting on Lord Buddha’s teachings.
You are pathetic as human being and not a good Buddhist !!
You and your Mass Murderer Buddy-Rajapaksa will be punished by well deserved Karma
Again you’re spitting on Lord Buddha’s teachings with your abusive speech. Don’t you feel embarassed? Please stop spitting on Lord Buddha’s teachings..
Again you’re spitting on Lord Buddha’s teachings with your abusive speech. Don’t you feel embarassed? Please stop spitting on Lord Buddha’s teachings.
I think this is total stupidity, nothing else. Why, the police couldn’t give them some warning and advice before taking it to the court. How much money we’ve lost in this process? When people breaks heads and other parts of Buddha statues in seeking “Nidhan” no one cares; even, so called patriotic Buddhists.
Corporal punishment is the solution to this. A good round of caning (like in Singapore) or public flogging (like the middle east) and wide publicity worldwide would stop this once and for all. We are very soft people. End result is, everybody taking advantage of this weakness. Try doing this to the statue of mother mary in Lourdes and see what will happen. The mob will set on you. Yeah, those buggers are not as civilized as they say. Not that we are any better. But still…………
To me it has nothing to do with religion. It’s only good manners and basic decency to treat with respect what others may consider sacred. Especially if you are a visitor and the others in this case are your hosts. I doubt that the French tourists would have faced much harassment. They would have immediately contacted their embassy, which would have acted fast to help their countrymen.
We dont have to bend over backwards to pander to rude tourists. What we should do to promote tourism is give tourists value for their money, ie. provide a proper service when they pay for it (which I dont see happening).
The courts would have done what they had to do. I’m not aware what our government’s reaction exactly was, but I could guess that it went characteristically over the top.
Shammi,
just have a look at my comments above and also at the link posted.
Jack,
I think what the photographer did was calculated to make his work sell. That doesn’t bother me personally, but he may have hurt some people, which is not nice. My only thought was that he ought to go get his urine tested, if that’s the colour it is. And that is Australia, this is Sri Lanka. Imagine how some Autralians would react if we said Shane Warne was a chucker.
About Kalpitiya, I dont like how the government is said to have aquired the land, but if they build and market the resorts well and offer a service to match the rates, I’m sure the islands will sell. The French kissing episode wont make that much of an impact.
I dont disagree with anything Hattotuwa said.
http://www.colombotelegraph.com/index.php/french-kissing-the-buddha/
I did actually like that photograph, there is real artistry there. I had heard of the picture but actually looked it up only now because of the argument.
The full story on the land is that these were all distributed amongst cronies who tried very hard to flog them at massive premiums. The problem was that at the prices asked no project was viable. These were being touted privately for at least a couple of years if not more.
Now they are following a slightly more open approach, to see what interest is aroused, however the growing questions over governance will make it a lot harder to sell. The latest change at the SEC is symbolic of this.
Finding investors now may be a real problem.
You liked it? Couldn’t he get the same effect with tea or scotch champagne then? He was making a statement.
I believe that the issue at hand is primarily one of double standards. On the one hand, the affluent European visitor elevates his status the moment he “disembarks” at Bandaranaike International Airport, where he connects the anecdotal accounts of Sri Lankan hospitality with the subservient deferrence he experiences from his hosts.
Therefore, when he sets forth on his excursions, he has reinforced his status as an exalted “other” (by most accounts due to his white skin) and because he finds himself in a “third” world country with poor people. Condescension and polite niceties aside, he does acquire a superior status that predisposes him to act irresponsibly (if he wishes), given the above, and the seeming “soft”ness of the “locals”.
A dark-skinned visitor from Asia in places of worship or otherwise in Europe, North America or Australia will automatically feel the opposite and be very responsible in his behaviour as he will be humbled, awed and feel inferior from the time he sets foot at the white man’s door.