Who Is Male Or Female (In Sport)

Caster Semenya

Caster Semenya by José Goulão


In two recent cases the gender of athletes has been questioned. Both times, the issues and the women involved had the disputes play out in public with little respect for their humanity. Internationally, Caster Semenya was subjected to a vague and invasive gender testing process, which played out in public. The International Olympic Committee has apologized has set a policy based on testosterone levels. In India, however, gender issues in sport have played out worse.

In India, former athlete Pinki Pramanik has been arrested after her live-in (female) partner charged her with rape. Pramanik, despite identify as and competing as a female, has been kept in a male prison ward and been taken to and from dubious gender tests by male prisoners. Video from one of these medical tests was recorded and has ended up on the Internet. Whatever the charges may be, this is no way to treat a person, a woman, and certainly not an athlete that’s represented her country.

Gender is more of a continuum than people think, since people can have both male or female characteristics. It’s been said that Parliament could do anything except make a woman a man, but that’s actually not true. Gender is actually something that’s socially decided and the physical characteristics and definitions can be changed. People can have internal testes and be women or internal ovaries and be a man. Many people find this out later in life and have to decide. For sport there has to be some sort of line, but gender tests make no sense. I guess testosterone levels kinda do, both in that they’re objective, not inherently invasive and affect performance. In life, however, gender is largely a socially mediated choice. An obvious choice for most of us, but it is important to consider the many people at the blurry edges of gender identity, and not to hurt them for where they fall on a bell curve.

RSS feed | Trackback URI

2 Comments »

2012-07-10 14:14:58

I disagree that testosterone levels are “objective”. Men and women may have different testosterone levels but these can vary depending on age, time of the day and, more importantly, the level of training. And testing blood levels cannot differentiate between natural and artificial sources (i.e. those who just happen to have high testosterone or those who take it illegally).

 
2012-07-28 10:34:42

[...] games have seen the Olympic committee setting testosterone levels as a gender marker, letting a South Sudanese runner compete independently under the Olympic flag, and allowing a [...]

 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

email indi AT indi.ca.


Recent Comments


Police Protection (1)

billy: Can decentralizing power prevent ” a DIG turning contract killer”?

Internet Explorers (6)

sharanga: Sure, but that is only if you show promise. Big corporations won’t buy you simply because you have a good idea if it’s not clear your idea has the potential to make money. And seriously, if you have the potential to make...

Editor: Good show indi! Please see the event coverage by techwire.lk: http://techwire .lk/internet-en trepreneurship- forum-rotaract- club-of-usjp/

abdussamad: The idea is to get taken over by a larger company. In the meantime you try to get venture capital funding to sustain you. I don’t know if this will work in Sri Lanka though.

The YAMU Android App (2)

abdussamad: “like 6,000 lines of code we’re not using” Two questions a) since when can you code? b) how many lines is the final app?

Dave: When is it going to be available on the Apple App store?

Pay Pal Soon (4)

Hash M: Mashallah, insha allah? did i miss something indi?

Japanese People Drinking Beer On Sigiriya (6)

Gungan: There are more Sinhalese vandalising and stealing off archaeological sites/museums/ temples today and causing more damage than any foreign adverts presently. Sri Lankans need to chill a bit more. Have a beer!

Malik: Think about the benefits of this. At least the world will know about Sigiriya this way.

Are Tamils The 4th Ethnicity Now? (6)

Pulasthi: How could you say tamils settled in sri lanka during the begining of sinhalese,,,,yo u are wrong cholas invaded sri lanka even after centuries… ;.and permenently tamils sheltered after maga in 1215….don t public faulse...

Police Protection

Not to quote Ice Cube, but the Sri Lankan police are hardly beloved. A DIG was recently arrested for conspiring to murder a businessman, ie be a hit man. On the low levels reports of police torture and abuse are widespread. Low-ranking policemen are usually the ones disciplined, if at all, but this fish is really rotting from the head. The Sunday Times has a good piece on how the people at the top don’t get punished and how the structure of the government leads to corruption and abuse on the streets.

Internet Explorers

I just gave a talk at the University Of Sri Jayawardenapura along with Reeza Zarook of Anything.lk and Rohan Jayaweera of Google. These are my notes: Devin Jayasundara asked me for a subject for this talk and I told him Internet property. But I talked to my fiancé Shru and she had a better idea. Startups aren’t about creating property at all, not really. They’re about creating territory, about creating land.

The YAMU Android App

I haven’t been blogging much, I know. It’s partly because we’ve been doing a lot of work on YAMU, especially shipping 1.0.1 of the Android app today. It’s on the Google Play Store now. Inosh Perera did the programming (learning Android in the process) and Janith helped out with some design. My main contribution was a bunch of dead-end designs and like 6,000 lines of code we’re not using. The app isn’t perfect but it’s more perfect than it was 10 iterations ago. We think it’s pretty good.

Japanese People Drinking Beer On Sigiriya

I met an old-timer who said they used to drop acid and sleep atop Sigiriya, but the place has taken on a more commercial and quasi-spiritual role now. It was built by a king as a sort of retreat and used as a monastery. Now it’s a prime tourist and cultural destination. Hence it’s a bit odd to see a Japanese beer commercial shot up there. There’s a bunch of people eating, um, deep fried cream filled coconuts and then drinking some bracing beer. I hear the whole thing cost Rs. 25,000 (I’m presuming they used stock images).