Americans Suck At Arranged Marriages

Wedding Cake


You know that Internet time-suck where you click one sidebar link and end up in a gossip vortex? So yeah, I went there. This slideshow was about how long ‘Bachelor’ relationships last, Bachelor being the TV show that fixes up what looks to Asians like expensive and demeaning arranged marriages.

The length of a Bachelor/Bachelorette curated relationship seems to be a few months, with the exception of Season 1, which ended in marriage. So that’s a pretty bad run for arranged marriages.

In Asia, however, this rate of failure on an arrangement would be unthinkable. I think the difference is that the Bachelor (in the bits I’ve seen) builds up to marriage with traditional western dating events, in a sort of sporting format. The trouble here is that western dating doesn’t naturally end in marriage, the goal is usually sex. So it’s like having a series of 100-meter trials for a marathon final. Furthermore, the emphasis in these shows seems to be on the individuals and true love. As in, if these people click, you can throw them into a media maelstrom and they should be fine.

In eastern arrangements, however, the emphasis is on making the elements around the couple click – finances, career, families. These are the pressure points that break apart couples, often no matter how much they like each other. Aside from ensuring that the man is rich, the B shows make no particular effort to align the rest. They essentially throw a rich man into a harem and expect him to marry one. But that’s not generally how the harem model works.

If they actually wanted a better marriage rate, I guess I’d recommend hiring a few Asian aunties as consultants, and making it a family show rather than a bunch of pretty singles in a house. Have groups of families meet each other and have more than two people involved in the marriage bond. Seriously, no self-respecting matchmaker would allow half the shenanigans you see on these TV shows, and you’d see a lot more marriages. Babies even.

RSS feed | Trackback URI

7 Comments »

Gamaraala
2012-07-23 16:29:27

Arranged Marriages are sign of a primitive unsophisticated undeveloped society. It shows lack of social skill and a weak society were people are not comfortable with talking with each other. In fact this can be used as a yardstick to determine development level of a country. The more arranged marriages than love marriages definitely implies weak undeveloped society.

kp
2012-07-23 17:24:32

and yet, its these “undeveloped, primitive” societies that have much stabler marriages. way to understand the point of the article, putha

Gamaraala
2012-07-23 17:30:21

In a strong society (Like US) it does not matter if the divorce rate is high. Since people are independent and socieity is advanced they can survice on their own until they find other spouses. Also there is no discrimination like here if you are divorced, especially for women. So it dosn’t really matter about stable and unstable marriages.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
makin
2012-07-24 00:18:00

It does if children are involved putha.

 
 
 
Acro
2012-07-26 09:48:27

A typical, undeducated sentiment

 
 
Carasek
2012-07-23 18:20:10

Not sure the producers’ motivation is a better marriage rate!

Over half of the arranged marriages amongst my friends have ended in divorce. These are second or third generation British Asians, subject to all the social support, but much less of the social stigma vis-a-vis their Indian contempories.

I’m pretty sure that if the majority in South Asia had the social, financial, religious and familial opportunities that most have in the West, there would be far fewer unhappy marriages and far more divorces.

The opposite’s probably true also: people give up on marriage in the West, perhaps earlier than they should. On balance, is happiness preferable to stability? I think so.

makin
2012-07-24 00:30:43

Disagree. SL buddhist style arranged marriages where the couple have a choice has a good track record. Not so sure about the others. But the process works well in most cases. Most British Asians I know want to marry white people so obviously being forced to marry another Asian would suck big time. So this is a mute point. The western model of marrying someone based mainly on your past good sex life is doomed to fail. As any married man will tell you the amount of sex you get after marriage is inversely proportional to the time married.lol.

 
 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

email indi AT indi.ca.


Recent Comments


Police Protection (6)

billy: i doubt it, rather will create more killers instead of just one…

tastyjujubes: Apparently some Tamil protesters screaming against the Sri Lankan cricket team got slapped silly in London.

Jack Point: Kenya is trying to reform its police force. The document below lists some the steps needed to restore its independence. http://www.amne sty.org/en/libr ary/asset/AFR32 /001/2013/en/9c 3fb77e-16e2-49e 0-94ec-d3c9f0e9 f9e2/afr3200...

Internet Explorers (6)

sharanga: Sure, but that is only if you show promise. Big corporations won’t buy you simply because you have a good idea if it’s not clear your idea has the potential to make money. And seriously, if you have the potential to make...

Editor: Good show indi! Please see the event coverage by techwire.lk: http://techwire .lk/internet-en trepreneurship- forum-rotaract- club-of-usjp/

abdussamad: The idea is to get taken over by a larger company. In the meantime you try to get venture capital funding to sustain you. I don’t know if this will work in Sri Lanka though.

The YAMU Android App (2)

abdussamad: “like 6,000 lines of code we’re not using” Two questions a) since when can you code? b) how many lines is the final app?

Dave: When is it going to be available on the Apple App store?

Pay Pal Soon (4)

Hash M: Mashallah, insha allah? did i miss something indi?

Japanese People Drinking Beer On Sigiriya (6)

Gungan: There are more Sinhalese vandalising and stealing off archaeological sites/museums/ temples today and causing more damage than any foreign adverts presently. Sri Lankans need to chill a bit more. Have a beer!

Police Protection

Not to quote Ice Cube, but the Sri Lankan police are hardly beloved. A DIG was recently arrested for conspiring to murder a businessman, ie be a hit man. On the low levels reports of police torture and abuse are widespread. Low-ranking policemen are usually the ones disciplined, if at all, but this fish is really rotting from the head. The Sunday Times has a good piece on how the people at the top don’t get punished and how the structure of the government leads to corruption and abuse on the streets.

Internet Explorers

I just gave a talk at the University Of Sri Jayawardenapura along with Reeza Zarook of Anything.lk and Rohan Jayaweera of Google. These are my notes: Devin Jayasundara asked me for a subject for this talk and I told him Internet property. But I talked to my fiancé Shru and she had a better idea. Startups aren’t about creating property at all, not really. They’re about creating territory, about creating land.

The YAMU Android App

I haven’t been blogging much, I know. It’s partly because we’ve been doing a lot of work on YAMU, especially shipping 1.0.1 of the Android app today. It’s on the Google Play Store now. Inosh Perera did the programming (learning Android in the process) and Janith helped out with some design. My main contribution was a bunch of dead-end designs and like 6,000 lines of code we’re not using. The app isn’t perfect but it’s more perfect than it was 10 iterations ago. We think it’s pretty good.

Japanese People Drinking Beer On Sigiriya

I met an old-timer who said they used to drop acid and sleep atop Sigiriya, but the place has taken on a more commercial and quasi-spiritual role now. It was built by a king as a sort of retreat and used as a monastery. Now it’s a prime tourist and cultural destination. Hence it’s a bit odd to see a Japanese beer commercial shot up there. There’s a bunch of people eating, um, deep fried cream filled coconuts and then drinking some bracing beer. I hear the whole thing cost Rs. 25,000 (I’m presuming they used stock images).