How Rich Is Too Rich?

Palm Island World Island

In Dubai, they tried to remake the world for the wealthy. It failed. Image via NASA


Sam Harris has suggested that the rich pay more taxes, and he’s getting hammered for it. His readers are deep in the throes of the fundamental attribution error, thinking that individuals are responsible for everything that happens to them. Which isn’t true. Wealthy or poor, luck plays a lion’s role.

Our birth is random, we do not choose our parents, we do not choose our era and we do not choose the people around us. Yet these things all make a great difference to our rise or fall in life.

Harris is saying that billionaires et all need to be taxed more to improve society at large. His critics are saying that is survival of the fittest and that people who succeed shouldn’t have to subsidize those who fail. I agree with Harris, though I don’t object to the evolutionary argument at all. It is about survival, survival of the civilization at large. That’s why elites can’t control too many resources, and why as many people need to be empowered as possible. Because it makes a civilization more robust.

We need taxes and government action because it’s right, but also because it’s sensible. For two reasons.

1. Pissed off masses will revolt
2. We don’t know what talents we will need

Any society that cuts off its weakest is weakening itself. It’s like drawing the Sri Lanka cricket team from only prominent schools. A lot of talented kids were left out and the team was weaker for it. Now the team draws from the whole island (north just coming online) and they’re better for it.

You don’t know what talent you will need and you don’t know where it will come from, so the survival of a society is improved by its diversity. Because you have more options, more skills and more ways to adapt. Because you have more human capital, rather than a few humans with more capital. That’s what makes or breaks a civilization and it’s the only way to improve chances in an existence which is, ultimately, largely luck.

Anyways, Sam Harris, worth a read.

RSS feed | Trackback URI

Comments »

No comments yet.

Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

email indi AT indi.ca.


Recent Comments


Why Does India Suck At The Olympics? (7)

swan: Duuuuude! Why no blog on SF?

Carasek: Growing up, my only impression of the average Chinese was that they were hard as nails. John Woo, Bruce Lee and Jackie Chan movies will have that effect, of course.

David Blacker: First I’d like to see what the average Indian is. Or Chinese for that matter.

Unequal Marriage In Sri Lanka (The Foreign Kind) (18)

DK: My thanks to everyone – well, perhaps not Acro – who has contributed to this. I’ve learned a lot. As I’ve said in a previous string I’m Sri Lankan-born, lost SL citizenship because of prevailing laws at the time I...

New New Kottu (7)

Chavie: Thanks bro. :)

Chavie: Yeps, any combination of language/popula rity that you use to view a page can be used to obtain a feed. Let’s say you’re looking at Sinhala posts popular today: http://kottu.or g/si/today You can get the feed for that...

D: Can we get separate RSS feeds based on the language?

General Sarath Fonseka Out Soon? (12)

David Blacker: Nothing wrong with the Sinhalese being divided by politics rather than united by ethnicity. And yes, of course SL must cooperate with an international investigation if one is initiated. We can’t afford not to. The idea is to...

You’re Nobody Till (45)

Regewaypere2: Asortyment uzupe?nia Outcast przestrzenna uciecha przygodowa i klisza Setnie Speedway. Nu?e na godzin? poprzednio wschodem s?o?ca nieruchomosci odby? wspomnian? z wykorzystaniem Benwolia przechadzk? w gaju sykomorowym mamy w...

Sarath Fonseka And Minority Politics (9)

tastyjujubes: Being more “Tamil 221; is not going to help the Sri Lankan Tamils to be honest. Being even more insular, introverted and ethnocentric is not going to help the Tamil people. The Tamils of Sri Lanka live on an island with a...

Why Does India Suck At The Olympics?

Today on the morning show we talked about the Olympics, namely China’s emerging dominance. For me the bigger question is India. Why does India suck so much? In 2008 the US won 110 medals, China won 100 and India won… 3. India has over a billion people, some economic clout and is by all counts an emerging superpower, but they suck at the Olympics. Why?

New New Kottu

Janith has updated Kottu with rims and shit. Seriously, it looks pretty good. You could say the desktop look is cosmetic, but check out the mobile. Kottu now looks like an app with settings and menus and such. The biggest problem with K2 is me, ie, it now takes me up to a month to respond to emails. OMG I’m scared of my email. But Janith’s done this code and design update all by himself and it looks pretty good. Check it out. There was one bug with the previous page link. Lettuce know if there’s any more.

Miss Travel. Alternately, Mistravel

This is highly dubious. Miss Travel is a travel/social networking site that connects ‘Generous’ and ‘Attractive’ travelers. To, like, travel together, I guess. It all seems a bit like arranged prostitution and trafficking. This is part of a broader online trend to connect rich men to younger, attractive women. Sites like seekingarrangement.com connects women to ‘sugar daddies’ already. I guess Miss Travel is just taking that trend international. Wait, I checked, it’s the same guy doing both.

Buying Appliances Online (Singer)

Sri Lankan domestics never say anything, they just stop coming. My maid just stopped coming and when I finally pressed her she said I needed to get a washing machine. I was hoping to ride this one out, but I’ve run out of underwear and I have no choice. I finally caved and bought a washing machine, from Singer, ONLINE. I put the online in all caps because it’s pretty awesome. I ordered the thing in like 15 minutes on Saturday and they just delivered it today. It’s pretty awesome, this brave new world.