Diversity In The Diaspora (And Home)

Myself, dressed as Mahinda, representing South Asian races in a O/Level textbook. Literally, a walking contradiction


People ask about the Tamil diaspora as if they’re a monolithic unit. They’re not. The Sri Lankan Tamil diaspora has its share of crazies, its share of sanies and a much broader share of normal people just living their lives. It’s the same of people within Sri Lanka. Recently, I was reading the blog of a young diasporal who came back to Sri Lanka to visit (Serenstupidity). Her perspective is worth a read:

I’d like to stress how it is important not to base your perceptions on news reports. It is easy enough to believe that people in the country are all brainwashed and ridiculous. From my travels, I have gathered this is untrue. Citizens of Sri Lanka are just as stratified in their views as those in the diaspora. There are those who I’ve met, from Colombo intellectuals to villagers in the South, who are against the current administration. Then there are several of those I’ve met who genuinely believe that this must be the most amazing time for Tamil people to be free from war, and praise the president for “saving” Tamil people. There are also several who are completely politically apathetic. However you look at it, I hope people don’t brand Sri Lankans on the island as one monolithic group (Back In One Piece).

This is a crucial fact that a lot of people commenting on Sri Lanka miss. The rhetorical devices which are so convenient to use (Sinhala, Tamil, Tamil diaspora) don’t actually exist in any coherent form. They’re all full of contradictions and fundamentally misleading. How so? Here are a few contradictions:

Sinhala: This category includes Sinhala racists and people like me who, born Sinhala, don’t speak Sinhala or really participate in the culture. There is also a lot of Sinhala/Tamil mixing, even in the north. Sinhalese are a minority in Colombo.

Tamil: Abroad, this is thought to be a unitary race, represented by northern, Jaffna Tamils. In fact, around half of Tamils live in the south, the east is distinct from the north and even Jaffna Tamils are still heavily divided along caste lines. Tamils are also (usually) either Hindu or Christian, some speak English and home and some speak Tamil. Then there are up-country Tamils, descendants of labor imported by England, wanted and represented by basically no-one.

Tamil diaspora: There are like 900,000 people in the Tamil diaspora and they’re internally diverse. I know people who do a lot on the ground and talk about politics none. I know people who do nothing and talk a lot. I know those in between. I know people that aren’t involved at all, and I know people who are too involved with tech or art or whatever to care about politics at all.

So yeah. Sri Lankans are a bunch of different people. So are the diaspora. Race is only one thing that defines us, among many, and it’s not definitive. Personally, I thinking dividing suffering and rights based on race is like herding cats, or sculpting sand. If it takes you 30 years to do it, by then the demographics will have changed. Much simpler to focus on building a multi-ethnic society, based on equality for everybody.

RSS feed | Trackback URI

3 Comments »

2011-07-18 21:53:28

You made it into a textbook! Way to go :D

 
Magerata
2011-07-19 11:39:30

I have family friends who belongs to all three above and some Burger people as well and each and everyone of them have different ideals and ideas about SL. Most of them are much freer with us because we do not seem to belong to any of the above groups and tend to share or air their feelings and thoughts. You are right none of them will fit in any one basket. Neither do I.

 
2011-07-20 10:38:50

IMHO what matters is not the different groups of people who has different views. What matters is which group is running the show. I personally think its the wrong group running the show in both sides.

 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

email indi AT indi.ca.


Recent Comments


Monolithic Islam (5)

tastyjujubes: The Religion of Peace at work again: http://www.guar dian.co.uk/uk/2 013/may/22/wool wich-two-shot-i n-police-incide nt-live-coverag e

sharanga: Racial profiling is not racist if it works. Similarly, identifying groups among people is not wrong if it allows you to predict reality with reasonable accuracy. When you don’t know everything, you play the odds. For example, if I...

Dark Lord: Why is it so hard to buy pork anywhere in Sri Lanka? Most sellers don’t sell pork at all, or sell it only to known customers from a hidden storage at the back of the store, which goes like “don̵ 7;t tell anyone, we are...

40 Under 40 (6)

sharanga: Congratulations !

Malik: Looks like Mara and Co has blocked GossipLanka.com ????? What’s going on here??????????

Diyath: Congratulations Indi!.. All the best for your future tech endeavors!

Anti-Social Marketing (Nibras Bawa) (19)

David Blacker: Who cares, man? you’re still moaning on about a fight you lost months ago. It’s like the kid who gets his ass kicked then talk big later. You lost, you ran away like a whiney ponneya, and now you’re actually...

sharanga: A more accurate description would be I had my penis up your because you were refusing to answer a simple question. Now the fact that you thought I was not just Heshan, but also meechum just shows that you are stupid, and therefore your...

Chi Chi Hits The Scene, And A Referee (5)

sack: Indiz post about Gotabhaya had much more comments. http://indi.ca/ 2012/07/gotas-p uppy-hate/

Liberal One: He he, the article with the least number of comments out of Indi’s recent ones. Looks like no body wants to put their lives at risk by commenting on the wrong article. I’m off as well.

Monolithic Islam

Mohsin Hamid, author of How To Get Filthy Rich In Rising Asia, has a nice op-ed in the Guardian. Money quote for me was ‘Individuals are undeniably real. Groups, on the other hand, are assertions of opinion’. If you go buy news reports Muslims or Jews or Sri Lankans or any number of groups can appear monolithic and uniform. When you meet people, however, you find that they’re not. If you meet enough people you hopefully become aware of that tendency and judge people less by group identity in advance. Muslims, however, are quite publicly tarred with the same brush these days, and it really isn’t fair. Or accurate.

40 Under 40

I’m happy to be featured in Echelon magazine’s 40 Under 40 feature, profiling young people who contribute to the economy in some way, mainly in business but also in terms of innovation and thought leadership. It’s an interesting article not just in that I’m in it (mainly for work on indi.ca and Kottu but also YAMU) but also in that the magazine takes a bit of a critical stance. It’s worth reading the editorial (which I can only find in print) where they describe that only a few women are included and that all of the 40 are from middle to upper middle class backgrounds.

Chi Chi Hits The Scene, And A Referee

I won’t add too much commentary, but just read I guess. The youngest Rajapaksa, Rohitha (Chi Chi) has given an amazing interview to the Daily Mirror Life section, which is well worth a read. In other news, he also recently slapped a referee around in full public view at a rugby match. At least it seems that his elder brother restrained him.

Anti-Social Marketing (Nibras Bawa)

In 2009 this strange character appeared on the Sri Lankan Internet scene, getting angry, flaming, trolling whatever. Then he started naming anonymous bloggers, posting comments as people’s kids, nasty stuff, for which I removed him from Kottu. He also published some plagiarized stuff on Groundviews. He flamed out a bit more then disappeared. Until now. Now he’s back hosting a rather expensive social media event in Colombo, which is a bit ironic, seeing as he was known for being the most anti-social person the blogosphere had seen at the time.