Cracking The NYTimes Paywall Like An Egg

The New York Times office. Photo by eflon

The New York Times paywall is so leaky that cracking it is easier than subscribing to it. To crack a URL like[etc] I just need to remove the question mark and everything after it. In my web browser. I literally select some text with my mouse and hit delete. Alternately, this NYTClean bookmarklet does it with one click. I have no idea how long subscribing takes, but it seems complicated. Either the NYTimes thinks I’m really dumb or they think I’m really smart and are letting me in on the sly. Either way, I don’t get how this makes sense.

What I find a bit shocking is that this paywall cost $40 million dollars to implement. For that amount they could have presumably improved the product such that I would want to buy it other than putting a leaky fence around a product I’m used to getting for free. This is not to say that I wouldn’t like to pay for the New York Times. I actually wouldn’t mind. It’s not a charity gesture, however, give me something to buy.

There are two reasons to pay for something. Well, one really, but two flow out of it. The one reason is because you have to. The reasons that flow out of that are because you really have to and the other is because you have to and you want to. For example, at McDonald’s if you don’t pay they don’t give you food. At a restaurant you get food and pay after.

Online, people don’t really use the second model. Online I pay for a few things, I pay for extra storage on GMail, I pay for a music subscription at and I pay for WordPress Themes. These are things I cannot get any other way. If I don’t pay a bit more for GMail I have to delete mail, if I don’t pay for I can’t get customized radio. If I don’t pay for WordPress themes I have to spend time fixing up free ones. I think this model works, under a few conditions.

First off, they give me something better than I’m used to getting for free. They also save me time, which I’m willing to exchange for money. GMail gives me a shit ton of storage for free, but when I forward work mail and stuff it’s actually not enough. The paid option gives me untold gigabytes so I’m happy to buy. It saves me time in that I don’t have to pile through emails to delete them. learns the music I like and plays customized radio. This spares me having to download and curate my iTunes collection, a time saving service that I’m willing to pay for. WordPress Premium Themes are insanely sophisticated by now and save me hours of development time, months in some cases. They also make me look like a genius to clients, and help me make money. Definitely worth a buy.

The NYTimes paywall, however, offers me the same thing as the old free product and actually asks me for time to figure it out and register and keep logging in across various computers and devices. It’s actually crappier than the free product and more of a burden on my time. This would be a possible model if they secured it, ie, forced me to pay. The Times, however, doesn’t. It makes it easier for me to not pay (select/delete) and makes themselves look stupid in the process.

One thought is that they think I’m going to crack it anyway and are letting me in. That the paywall is only for old people who don’t know what a URL is. That’s a bit of a weak business model, however, appealing to ignorance rather than reason. I am willing to pay. Just give me something extra to pay for and save me a bit of time.

For example, spend 40 million dollars integrating with Twitter and Facebook to provide me a social frontpage. Or apply some algorithms to figure out what I’m reading and recommend more stuff that I’d be interested in. Something that saves me time and makes me happy I’ll pay for. Incorporate social networking so anyone that doesn’t pay publicly look like an asshole, like someone who doesn’t tip at a restaurant. Spend 40$ million dollars making your site a bit cooler and then spend 15 minutes putting some decent access control with a fucking .htaccess text file, whatever.Reduce speeds for people that don’t pay, whatever.

You can either delight me into paying or force me to, but the NYTimes is doing neither. The end result is select, delete not because I’m a cheat but because they’re not even trying to make a sale.

RSS feed | Trackback URI


The way of the Dodo
2011-03-31 14:17:42

does this mean you’re a criminal of sorts.

Merinas van der Lubbe
2011-04-08 09:54:23

What’s a “New York Times”??

2011-04-17 13:30:42

I think you’re mistaken. $40 million for a “paywall”, and you can by pass it like that. Ha ha ha…. Can you tell me how to reproduce this phenomenal multi-million dollar crack?

Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

email indi AT

Recent Comments

What A Colombo Revolution Might Look Like (Thailand) (7)

Liberal One: Very well written. The sad thing is this section of the society has taken hold of UNP and were so determined not to see the party under a Premadasa or a D.B Wijethunga again, completely destroyed the party with their various...

Shirley Silva: Good analysis but you failed to mention that unlike in Bangkok a good shower would send the UNPs scuttling home. Above all there is a big leadership vacuum. No charismatic leader like in Thailand

Israel And Sri Lanka: War And Proportionality (1)

Jack Point: Hmmm Not quite sure if proportionality is the right word to use. The argument I think is on the lines of the end justifying the means. Certainly, of the two Israel looks far worse, more wanton. The peace of Sri Lanka is however a...

How The BBS Attacks (A Tale Of Two Cities) (6)

Jack Point: The BBS is tapping into resentments that are buried deep in the subconscious. What they do it to tap in to them, nurture them and magnify them. Exactly what 969 is doing. Exactly what the Nazi’s did. http://jestfork icks.blogsp...

shammi: But you do agree that not arresting G.A. Gnanasara and any other lawbreakers from both sides will only serve to deepen this mistrust? If you don’t, you must be living in said land.

Liberal One: I was talking about the distrust between Sinhalese and Muslims. If you think distrust between these two communities didn’t exist before Gnanasara thero entered the scene you must be living in the la la land of the Colombians.

Damian Poosa (2000-2014) (1)

greene: innalillahi wa inna ilaihi raajioon.

Buddhism And Racism (2)

Johan: Temples tend to be quite skilled at fund raising for building projects within temple premises; perhaps they could mobilise those skills to raise funds to rebuild the damage wrought in Aluthgama and Beruwela. If you go to a particular...

Nandasiri Wanninayaka: Nice to see you are blogging again.

Anti Christian Christmas (2)

Jack Point: I found this video very disturbing. v=EUHCQyxK3ps&a mp;feature=yout http://dbsjeyar hives/27450

Israel And Sri Lanka: War And Proportionality

In both Gaza and Mullativu, militants embedded within civilian populations were bombed at great human cost. What makes these cases different? In short, I’d say the difference is proportionality. Many civilians died in Sri Lanka, but a decades long war was ended. They died for a proportional military objective. In Palestine, however, many civilians died for the Israeli’s to find some tunnels and slow down some mostly ineffective rocket fire. That was not, in my opinion, a military objective proportional to killing so many civilians, destroying so much infrastructure and collectively punishing a population they already held under siege.

Damian Poosa (2000-2014)

Our family cat Damian passed away last night. He was an American cat and it was fitting that he passed on the Fourth Of July. Damian was an ornery cat made happy by the love and care of my sister and parents. I brought him home on the day of my high school graduation (a stunningly thoughtless thing, in hindsight) and my sister and mother actually raised him. He then travelled back to Sri Lanka and had a great time till he got old.

How The BBS Attacks (A Tale Of Two Cities)

This seems to be the basic BBS gameplan (for fucking up everything we’ve worked so hard to build after the war). It’s a cycle of outrage, riot, fear, repeat. It’s like the eightfold path to not being a Buddhist:

Buddhism And Racism

Buddhism is not racist. The ideas and practice of Buddhism involve meditation, perception of impermanence and ultimately what we would call a renunciation of self. Being a Buddhist, however, is not just that. Being a Buddhist fundamentally involves taking refuge in three things – the Buddha, the Dhamma (his teachings) and the Sangha (the community of practice). As a Buddhist, this is why the violence in Aluthgama is so troubling. Becomes it comes cloaked in the colors of the Sangha. The main racists and instigators of mob violence are monks.