The Mona Sarika Saga


Mona Sarika once cited me as a proud Tamil and made up a bunch of quotes for a Huffington Post article. I complained and that article got pulled. Now, however, she’s been caught doing the same thing on the Wall Street Journal, and Foreign Affairs, and her whole career is in flames. My first impression of her was that she was a bit dumb. I’m surprised it got this far.

When I spoke to her she clearly had her own narrative going in and she just wanted some names to fill in the quotes and the story she was making up. I told her repeatedly that I wasn’t Tamil but she somehow cited me as one, a sorta LTTE supporting one at that.The article was pulled and I thought nothing further of it.

The Saga Continues, And Broadens

My main impression of Ms. Sarika was that she was an dumb. I mean that not in a malicious sense, I just don’t know how else to put it. She couldn’t seem to do basic reporting (like tracking down real Tamil people) or even figure out what race I was. She didn’t spell stuff right and rather than responding to emails would just ask the same questions over and over. I couldn’t understand how she got work with the Huffington Post but that’s kind a blog site and I sorta understood. Later I found out that she was getting work at Foreign Affairs, The Wall Street Journal and all over, and she was making shit up and plagiarizing there. So now her bullshit has blown up everywhere, including on the Huffington Post (where she’s now banned), and the Hindustan Times, and with retractions on the WSJ and Foreign Affairs.

Which is all well and good, but what were these guys thinking? First off, her articles suck. They’re just not very well written. Second, whenever I add anyone to Kottu (which is a small, local blog aggregator) I copy any suspicious text and paste it into Google. If it returns a match then I tell them it’s plagiarizing and I can’t include it. To check Ms. Sarika that’s literally all I did, but that seems beyond the ken of the editors at the Wall Street Journal, The Huffington Post and Foreign Affairs. Except it’s not, they should just do that. Also, when I report the first plagiarism the HuffPost just pulled the post. She then went on to burn other news organizations. I think this sort of transgression should be made public, otherwise it repeats.

But well, that name has been burnt pretty globally, and the Hindustan Times hammered her pretty hard. Let’s hope it doesn’t happen again.

RSS feed | Trackback URI

3 Comments »

Comment by Hmm
2009-12-10 07:08:44

She’s not so different to the NGO activists in Sri Lanka. She’s simply feeding her gullible liberal Western audience, the racist, self-serving garbage they want to read. At least this person got caught. How about the hundreds of Ngots in Sri Lanka who make up similar crap to get money from their donors.

 
Comment by Sagara
2009-12-13 10:00:19

agree with hmm. this is exactly what the ngo bottom feeders do in the name of the oppressed. spout bullshit from ‘sources’ and then fly off to collect more money to feed their nightclub lifestyles. shame on them all.

 
Comment by myil selvan
2009-12-14 00:32:42

1. This is not surprising.
2. To Sagara and Hmm – it’s always easy to attack those whom you don’t agree with
3. Only those who lost know the great work of the NGOs to rebuild this nation after the tsunami.
4. Even Indi is somewhat guilty of not checking facts. I remember Indi saying, “the sri lankan govt forces are not guilty of organised terrorism”, in reply to one of my posts. So, who can I complain to about that errornous line? The GoSL????? Hypocrisy can be a virtue!

 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

email indi AT indi.ca.


Recent Comments


The Military State Of Mind:
  • jcnars: @rubbish, you hit the coin. Indi seems to have sold his soul of late. Sucking up to the govt. like a pro. @girigor, talking loud doesn't always means talking sense. We are in a period between wars, if: a) nuts like you don't STFU and b) china is allowed a naval base in SL....
  • Girigoris the One: Tamils are being mistreated, Sinhalese should understand blah blah blah Yoy say "But for the sinhalese people, they find it good that the armed forces are around because almost all of them are sinhalese and past experience shows they will favour their own people, sadly." Tell me when the LTTE was around, did they even allow normal Sinhalese peeps to walk in to their area freely? Where were you then? Did you complain to the LTTE why...
  • myil selvan: dear indi, You as a Canadian sinhalese may find it hard to comprehend the nature of militarization. But for the sinhalese people, they find it good that the armed forces are around because almost all of them are sinhalese and past experience shows they will favour their own people, sadly. But for the Tamil people, they see it as an occupying force not interested in their welfare but only in holding real-estate. The coming days, months are...
The Last Jail Of The Last King:
  • prasad: I remember it being octagon shaped. Maybe my memory is playing tricks on me....
  • Jack Point: Rather appropriate that the cell is in the Ceylinco premises. Perhaps their former chairman should occupy that rather than the cell in Welikada?...
  • Shammi: Thanks for spying out these little gems. I think there were two wives with him at the time of his capture and incarceration. Have you seen the bit of the old fortifications of Colombo left within the premises of the Commercial Bank building in Fort? Beware of the suspicious security guard there!...
Did Little Children Create God?:
  • Shammi: It's funny the way most of the stories and rituals in the bible have so much in common with legends of more ancient pagan civilizations. Bits of the tales of Gilgamesh, Dionysus et al are mirrored in the descriptioons of Noah, Moses, Jesus, the Holy Trinity and the holy family etc., even a trace of Solomon reflected in Mahoshada of the jataka tales. They could've been a little more creative at least. I think I'm...
  • Whacko: the question is why we stop asking these questions when we are adults...
  • Kids Say: No, little children didn't create god - insecure and ignorant people did. Believing in and worshipping a magical invisible creature in the sky gives a lot of people comfort and security. That said, little children can be wonderfully creative. Have you seen the show "Kids Say the Darndest Things"? (You can watch clips of the show on youtube). This sounds like something from that show: Christianity is the belief that a cosmic Jewish zombie who...
The Colombo Lighthouse, Chaitya Road:
  • magerata: Never been there, thanks Indi, will make an effort next time....
  • Chavie: I think we should thank Racially-stereotyping tards like you for making it all possible....
Othello:
  • Electra: Actually race has little to do with what Othello is actually about. Of course it does make an appearance here and there, but it's possible that the race theme has been slightly over-analysed (as is most of Shakespeare's work) by later interpreters. However - it deals with the equally potent themes of jealousy, obsession, paranoia, the idea of masculinity. To me those are the things that makes Othello a truly remarkable account of what is...

Related Posts


Bad Journalism In Huffington Post

Mona Sarika wrote an article in the Huffington Post and cited me as Tamil. I'm not. I repeatedly told her so. She also makes up whole parts of my quotes and changes them to say something completely radical and different. In her article she writes "I spoke to many Sri Lankan Tamils, but most of them were reluctant to divulge any information fearing government reprisals. However, a few did respond. One was Indi Samarajiva". Literally

Sarath and US

The US seems to be trying to get General Sarath Fonseka to testify against Gotabaya or something. I think this is wrong, and they're doing it in a bumbling and incompetent fashion. These guys are assholes, but they're our assholes. Any investigation needs to come from Sri Lanka. The US should investigate Dick Cheney if their conscience pricks them so.

Urban Thongs Beach Party

I always thought a Sri Lankan gossip blog would be in order, like Gawker. In its own vitriolic way that's where the fart factory seems to be going. He seems to be becoming a gossip columnist, albeit one that hates his subjects. Of course, bloggers are in no way celebre, though he's treating them that way. The fact that someone would give a shit where we go on Saturday is actually kinda sweet. And I