The Battle Of The Bundi


A few years ago I started getting prematurely middle aged. For Sri Lankan men this generally means a belly, or bundi. I’ve always eaten or done whatever, but for the first time I thought about it. For one thing I was drinking too much, and eating too much, and not exercising at all. I changed most of that, but I think the main thing is really diet. I think exercise is good for you, but exercise alone doesn’t necessarily help you lose weight.

Exercise

This is surprising, and I hate saying ‘most studies’, but most studies show that exercise alone doesn’t really help you lost weight. It can give you muscle and really elevate mood, but it doesn’t necessarily burn fat.

“The message of our work is really simple,” although not agreeable to hear, Melanson said. “It all comes down to energy balance,” or, as you might have guessed, calories in and calories out. People “are only burning 200 or 300 calories” in a typical 30-minute exercise session, Melanson points out. “You replace that with one bottle of Gatorade.” (New York Times)

Someone like Michael Phelps can burn thousands of calories, but most people can’t and don’t exercise that much. Not that exercise can’t help – ““If you work out at an easy intensity, you will burn a higher percentage of fat calories” than if you work out a higher intensity, Carey says, so you should draw down some of the padding you’ve accumulated on the hips or elsewhere — if you don’t replace all of the calories afterward.”

Diet

For that to work, however, the normal diet has to change, dramatically. In Sri Lanka we have rice for two, maybe three meals a day. In a typical bath packet the rice is the ocean to little archipelagos of vegetable and meat. We also eat a lot of food quite late in the night, and sleep on it. Kottu is only served at night, and typical dinner parties serve the food at like 10, when you’re mind-numbingly ravenous. Paradoxically, as you can afford more Kottu and dinner parties, you’re also less inclined to walk or carry stuff or move around that much. So we get a plethora of food, mostly starch, mostly carbs mostly going to the belly.

When I was living alone I lost weight just by virtue of being out of that social scene. I didn’t eat breakfast, ate a rice lunch at work and didn’t eat dinner. Not very healthy at all but I lost some of my head fat at least. On the weekends I’d order pizza in the morning and eat that throughout the day. This is still a dumb way to live. Now I eat breakfast and lunch and skip dinner, unless I have to eat socially. I eat breakfast at about 11 and lunch before 6, but I try not to eat after dark. I also take max two spoons of rice. Sometimes I fuck up and keep reserving myself a teaspoon at a time like that doesn’t add up, but I’m generally losing my appetite for it.

Now I can eat one spoon of rice with twice as much purippu and be perfectly happy with that. It looks paltry when served but while eating I don’t actually want to finish it. I eat as much meat and vegetables as I want, and I eat fruit whenever.

Diet Plus Exercise

Of course, that still leaves me a bit chubs, but I started exercising every day and now I think I’ve reached some sorta energy balance. I guess it’s easy cause I don’t actually eat for pleasure. If I’m left alone I generally won’t eat until I get ravenous, and that mainly so I don’t die. I’ve learned how to cook from a young age, but I have become generally suspicious of any sense pleasure in my quarter age. So anyways, as I near 30 I’m trying not to look that way. Balancing exercise and diet (mainly diet) helps.

RSS feed | Trackback URI

8 Comments »

2009-11-30 10:42:08

[...] For lunch I have a homemade bath packet which includes red rice, dhal, kathurumurunga kola mallum and karavala. That should be healthy enough methinks. Should go easy on the rice though. Fear of carbs has been increased today by disturbing visions of Indi battling his bundi. [...]

 
Comment by MiddleChild
2009-11-30 11:07:44

obsessing much?? :D

 
Comment by DD
2009-11-30 12:41:48

“but exercise alone doesn’t necessarily help you lose weight”

Indi

Yes it does. Especially cycling, walking, running and swimming. Not for about five minutes, a good half hour in the morning and another half hour in the evening.

Running and cycling in SL is easy because of the warm weather!

 
Comment by Dee
2009-11-30 12:57:57

Agree with DD. If you went for a low carb, leafy diet and do a form of exercise i’m sure you’d get into tip top shape.

 
Comment by indi
2009-11-30 13:13:13

i’m in ok shape now, this was a while ago

@DD exercise alone doesn’t work. That’s the finding of all of these studies, for years. It’s great holistically, but for weight loss it has to be combined with some change in diet. There’s an intersting debate in the comments of the Times article, but there’s no significant debate in the medical literatre. Exercise alone doesn’t really help one lose weight

 
Comment by myil selvan
2009-11-30 23:20:44

do some power walking on the treadmill for about 40 minutes every day or every other day
Break up your diet – eat snacks like four times a day
Go to sleep after 3 hours of finishing a meal or have an early dinner (or early snack)
These tips should help you to keep enjoying most things you’ve enjoyed before but at the same time reduce some weight
But if you want the six pack, then you can ask the experts

 
Comment by indi
2009-12-01 02:11:29

OK, everyone’s giving me advice which isn’t exactly the point. I was more interested in the study.

If you want to know, I usually eat two meals a day and either go to the gym or exercise at home every day. I think the exercise makes a huge difference in terms of muscle, but the fat seems mostly diet-related. What I take away from the this study and other studies (especially on low calorie diets) is that we’re eating too much for our modern level of activity.

But as for me personally, I exercise and eat pretty healthy, so I’m OK

 
Comment by sue
2009-12-05 12:52:59

I feel so sorry for you. I love my bath curry and the curries my maid prepares are soooooo good. I get depressed if I don’t eat rice. My daughter lost weight gradually by eating only boiled veges for lunch.

 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

email indi AT indi.ca.


Recent Comments


The English Speaking Elite:
  • Mahinda: This is sort of a forum, isn't it? What I mean is that Indi posts something, everyone has a quick read, then starts using this space to air their own views and spread their own message or start their own little (quite often completely unrelated) arguments or whatever... Its got an organic quality, which I think is quite nice......
  • The way of the Dodo: I think we should take some of this stuff and create a forum. That allows for better discussion and more mature dialog. What do you guys think...
  • Mahinda: Just curious... Didn't mean to offend....
Much More Mahinda:
  • Mahinda: Lousy, uninteresting comeback with only mild entertainment value. Where's the wit? Where's the logic/justification to the comment? I'm disappointed in you......
  • David Blacker: Mahinda, I doubt you'd make a good bench press, never mind a press sec....
  • Mahinda: Machang Blacker! Where have you been??! Were you busy washing your hair or something? Oh sorry - you don't have hair, no? So why the offensive attitude? Don't you think I'd make a good press sec? ;)...
The Final Cross:
  • Mahinda: Flyovers, if effectively used, are an excellent method of improving the flow of traffic and congestion. Since you guys don't think the ones that have been built work terribly well towards that objective, lets just blame Mahinda and the Government for this and move on :) Ok. That was just a little joke, but on a serious note, I think development should be well thought out and also implemented in the most cost effective manner. Which...
  • Anon: To add to what Dodo say, before the fly-over there was stop-go traffic at the Dehiwala junction. After the flyover there is a continuous, but slow flow of traffic. Although I use that road only rarely in my limited experience the length of the queue and the time taken to travel is no better after the flyover, and may be slightly worse. Moving the bus stand would be an improvement at Dehiwala, think Nugegoda is somewhat more...
  • Anon: Thanks Shammi, there was a very good interview in the Nation a few years back that opened my eyes to him. Think he did a fair job at the port and according to reports did not take a large "grant" that was in the offing. Agree with Dodo that Mangala's chances of getting elected at the moment look pretty slip....

Related Posts


The Good Monkey Diet

If I ate more it would make my mother very happy. However, it may be healthier to eat less. The monkeys above are about the same age, but the one on a reduced calorie diet looks far better. His diet, however, sucks. A similar human named Vyff "eats once a day, usually a lean chicken breast poached in water, some steamed broccoli or squash and maybe a glass of fresh orange juice." The reason, I

Sri Lankan Towns Without A

At parties I end up talking to kids. This being Sri Lanka it's entirely natural to have three generations at a party, each entirely being themselves. As it should be. Often when I go out I feel like I'm talking to myself, or as a PR exercise. Kids are some of the few people that genuinely surprise me. Kids are often wrong, but not for lack of reasoning. If anything they reason more, albeit with

Wine and Health

I've been drinking red wine lately cause it makes me feel healthy, though deep in my heart I know the connection is bumpkis. According to the Times article, you'd have to drink 750 bottles per day to see a real benefit. In effect, drinking red wine has only moderate benefits and still gives you hangovers the next day. In refined pill doses, however, the red wine substance resveratrol seems to have great promise for both

Expectation of Life and Dinner

It's often said that villagers eat better than the cream of Colombo 7. Cream is, literally, bad for you. I've been doing some reading and apparently life expectancy dropped with the onset of agriculture, only recovering quite recently. Just as today the convenience of processed food has a heavy cost in terms of heart disease and obesity. Human progress in food has largely been quantitative rather than qualitative, more rather than better. Being a hunter

Brief History Of Food

Agriculture is a mixed blessing. It has enabled a boom in human population, leisure time, central government and civilization as we know it. Paradoxically, however, it lowered human life expectancy below Paleolithic levels (pre 10,000 BC) and made us more prone to famines and shortages. Cavemen ate a more varied and diverse diet than we do and until the 20th century they had a longer and healthier life (33 years compared to 20-30 in Medieval