Brief Visit To Menik Farm


I’m looking at the Sigiriya rock. It is a big rock and I understand why people wanted to climb it. Briefly got a glimpse inside Menik Farm yesterday. Basically just dropped off goods, talked to the coordinating doctor and left, so can’t say too much. Spoke to some people at Cheddikulam Hospital and it’s pretty much the same. Had two cows and a house in Kilinochchi, house got bombed, now here. Old woman said they hid in a ditch till they could flee. Played with a 3 month old baby and he didn’t say much but just goggled about.

Security is much less than it used to be a month ago. They still check everything at Medavachchiya, but not everything. They’re selling army t-shirts before the checkpoint that fit like paint. Spoke to a major there and he said security has to be ongoing. They are trying to sneak things up in false panels of trucks, etc. I also saw an Abans guy with a truck full of air conditioners and washing machines and stuff, which was new. He said the French and German doctors were putting air conditioners in their tents, so apparently there’s electricity. Before you scoff, it’s hot, the doctor’s keep getting sick and they deserve whatever comforts they can get.

Vavuniya town is the same as ever, bustling town. If you take the Mannar road from Medavachchiya (or loop around through the town as we did) you get to Cheddikulam. This is the hospital closest to the camps. Spoke to a fellow (with decent English) who said he’d got up at 6 am to get permission, gotten to the hospital at 2, didn’t know when he could go back. There was a bus running the route but it was packed.

Interesting thing is the Vavuniya way to Menik Farm is populated with older settlements, World Bank and UNHCR tsunami (I think) villages from 2003, 2007, etc. First things I saw was a kid in school clothes eating a popsicle and a mobile bank (People’s Bank I think). Road that way is absolutely gutted.

Cheddikulam Hospital is running, a lot of people reposted from Puttalam, Vavuniya, wherever. Many docs I spoke to had been there for a matter of weeks, so that staffing problem is improving.

Go down the way and through not especially stringent security and you’re in Menik Farm. It is basically a city of metal sheeting in the middle of not much. Better than your average slum where like 50% of Colombians live. It’s just the sheer scale. It literally goes on forever. There’s a decent road through and you can just clip and it doesn’t seem to stop.

Unloaded meds at the coordinating office and talked to the doctor who was understandably rushed. There’s a lot of stats around, they asked if I could help implement some IT solution, think some Excel sheets would do. Basically seems like cases of communicable diseases like Hepatitis A and Chicken Pox are kinda stabilizing but diarrhea is rising. The main problems are water and sanitation. He says if those improve then things will pretty much stabilize. It is honestly an insane scale of settlement in a short amount of time.

I don’t get why the international media wants to come in and gawk when Sri Lankans are suffering and the pictures are bad, but doesn’t want to see or help actual improvement. Wait, I do get it. The situation is way better than a month ago and better than even two weeks ago. I personally think they need to screen and resettle as soon as possible just cause wat/san is fundamentally unmanagable at this scale.

However, the doctors and all are doing a great job and getting quite sick and tired themselves. Working with ministry chappies is a bit annoying, but I’ve been nothing but impressed with the professionalism of the army. Talking to people from the camps they’re just tired. Exhausted really. The heat and conditions are not great and really won’t be. I’ve heard people say they shouldn’t complain and people say they really should. They don’t really do either, they’re just sorta living and waiting in line all day.

The main thing about going up there is the constant waiting. Even to get in you wait and wait and wait. The sides and political issues don’t seem so clear or relevant in the heat and dust. One just wants a drink, a bath and a decent meal. I don’t know. Heading back up to Vavuniya town and Puvarasakulam today.

RSS feed | Trackback URI

12 Comments »

Comment by fed up
2009-06-18 12:45:24

what is the purpose of these camps? what is the point of scrrening (it’ll take years) when the leaders are dead? if they “catch” an ltter these would b the options, imho,
1- shoot him
2- charge him and try him in courts (including lenghty investigations which are impossible, being the numbers so high)
3- release him (amnesty/pardon)
4- ?

so:
option 1= no go, i thought the shooting and unlawful justice are over (?)
option 2= what with this judicial “system” whihc is already a disaster, u wannna add thousands of court cases more??? insane.
option 3= the only viable solution, open the fucking gates u morons!

Comment by David Blacker
2009-06-18 14:54:39

I think 3 is applicable to most Tiger rank and file and even junior leadership. If charges are brought, it’ll probably be against higher ranking Tigers, and it will be terrorism-related ones. The bulk of LTTE personnel in the camps will be rehabilitated and repatriated. However, you must remember that there’ll be a lot of intelligence to be gathered from Tigers of all ranks (weapons caches, locations of minefields, bank accounts, logistical chains, whereabouts of personnel in the south, etc), and so interrogations will be done.

Comment by fed up
2009-06-18 20:31:41

and how r they going to extract this info? with or without lawyers? r they allowed in the camps to represent their clients? i thnk not to my knowledge…. anyone know about this fundamental right situation? wouldnt want it to be done us style either, or boossa style come to that….

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by David Blacker
2009-06-19 13:37:29

I assume it’ll be a military interrogation under the Emergency Regs. Though I use the word interrogation, I guess the level of coercion will depend on importance of info and levels of cooperation.

 
 
 
 
Comment by ying_yang
2009-06-18 14:07:14

Is there really nothing that concerned patriot’s can do? Why can’t we sign an electronic petition to the following effect:

affirming our commitment to a unified nation, pledging our support for the Governments efforts to address Tamil grievances, but at the same time deploring not only the appalling conditions but the very existence of the IDP camps which diminish the Army’s hard won successes on a daily basis.

Comment by fed up
2009-06-18 14:10:34

good one! u r a true patriot.

 
Comment by coconaut
2009-06-18 23:38:53

I’ll sign.

 
Comment by rajivmw
2009-06-19 01:57:49

Count me in. I believe there is finally a legal challenge under way spearheaded by the Centre for Policy Alternatives. Under the circumstances, this is heroic – and hopefully not quixotic.

 
Comment by N
2009-06-19 02:29:06

sounds like an eminently reasonable suggestion.

 
Comment by indi
2009-06-20 10:32:52

Electronic petitions are useless. They’re unreliable and make zero policy impact.

If you actually want to reach someone you can sign and send a letter to Major General Chandrasiri, the competent military authority for IDPs. Or Basil Rajapakse, really. Or the Ministry Of Social Justice. The furthest these guys go is fax.

 
 
Comment by venura
2009-06-21 03:21:23

ha ha to electronic petition. or any kind of petition. What is needed is people who can help solve the situation.

The issue is that the resettlement areas need to be built at least to some extent.

The govt can release people whom they are 100% sure that are not LTTE. People do get processed each day but they are not released because the have no place to go at present.

The entire situation is complex and can only be dealt with time and money.

This is one of those real life instance where arm chair solutions will not work.

You have to be part of that slow moving machine to understand the complexity of the issue.

Comment by coconaut
2009-06-23 23:01:08

Surely the govt would be hyping this up if it were true – I have seen no mention of any people who are free to leave, in the media. Would appreciate it if you could point me to a link.

If people ARE being cleared, why not process the people who have been asking (and even petitioning the courts) to leave, for weeks?

 
 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

email indi AT indi.ca.


Recent Comments


The English Speaking Elite:
  • Mahinda: This is sort of a forum, isn't it? What I mean is that Indi posts something, everyone has a quick read, then starts using this space to air their own views and spread their own message or start their own little (quite often completely unrelated) arguments or whatever... Its got an organic quality, which I think is quite nice......
  • The way of the Dodo: I think we should take some of this stuff and create a forum. That allows for better discussion and more mature dialog. What do you guys think...
  • Mahinda: Just curious... Didn't mean to offend....
Much More Mahinda:
  • Mahinda: Lousy, uninteresting comeback with only mild entertainment value. Where's the wit? Where's the logic/justification to the comment? I'm disappointed in you......
  • David Blacker: Mahinda, I doubt you'd make a good bench press, never mind a press sec....
  • Mahinda: Machang Blacker! Where have you been??! Were you busy washing your hair or something? Oh sorry - you don't have hair, no? So why the offensive attitude? Don't you think I'd make a good press sec? ;)...
The Final Cross:
  • Mahinda: Flyovers, if effectively used, are an excellent method of improving the flow of traffic and congestion. Since you guys don't think the ones that have been built work terribly well towards that objective, lets just blame Mahinda and the Government for this and move on :) Ok. That was just a little joke, but on a serious note, I think development should be well thought out and also implemented in the most cost effective manner. Which...
  • Anon: To add to what Dodo say, before the fly-over there was stop-go traffic at the Dehiwala junction. After the flyover there is a continuous, but slow flow of traffic. Although I use that road only rarely in my limited experience the length of the queue and the time taken to travel is no better after the flyover, and may be slightly worse. Moving the bus stand would be an improvement at Dehiwala, think Nugegoda is somewhat more...
  • Anon: Thanks Shammi, there was a very good interview in the Nation a few years back that opened my eyes to him. Think he did a fair job at the port and according to reports did not take a large "grant" that was in the offing. Agree with Dodo that Mangala's chances of getting elected at the moment look pretty slip....

Related Posts


Flooding In Menik Farm

Everyone's predicted that the rains would wreak havoc in the IDP camps, and they have. Groundviews has some of the only photos coming out of there and the Sunday Leader has a story today. I talked to someone in Menik Farm and there is indeed flooding, displacing people once again. It simply isn't possible to support a city-sized population in these conditions. A city of 250,000 has water and sanitation needs you can't construct overnight,

The Impossibility Of Camps

Sri Lanka can't afford to keep people in camps. I've seen direct requests for 1,000 latrines and 15,000 garbage bins. A latrine is about 15,000, so 15 million ($150,000). A garbage bin is like 1000 (I think) so another 15 mil. That's like $300,000 for a lot of 'infrastructure' in the middle of nowhere. No one will be living in Menik Farm in 5 years, but I've heard requests for 50,000 bags of cement. It'll

Mano Calls For Letting IDPs Out

I agree, and this charity thing is getting old. Charity sucks for a captive audience. I don't think it's 'state terrorism', not sure what that means beyond the normal state monopoly on violence. I do think it's bad public policy, legally illegal and expensively annoying. Hear that it's raining now, which SUCKS. If you want an idea of Menik Farm, think of the dusty outdoor parking lot behind Unity Plaza. The dust storms suck when

Let Our People Go

I'm writing this on the way back from Menik Farm. The roads are good. They're digging new drains. There seems to be enough medicine. People are growing vegetables and sewing clothes. Behind that, however, there is a weariness in people's eyes and a constant refrain on their lips. These people don't want charity anymore. They want to be free.

2010 Election In Photos

In what I hope will be the last of my election posts, here are some photos from Perambara. Mahinda Rajapaksa won, but there was a lot of drama and excitement along the way. I think the election was unfair, but power has its own demands and exigencies. So congratulations to Mahinda Rajapakse, if possible, it would be cool if this country could either follow the Constitution or change it, if only to reduce the chaos