On Kottu (What Next?)


I’m reluctant to post this. Kottu has always sorta been self-supporting. The server bills have gone up in the past year, but not dramatically. The code is a mess, but it works. As Notorious B.I.G. said, ‘mo money mo problems’ and Kottu has avoided that. However, the community has sorta stabilized at a certain size. Bigger is not necessarily better, but I think it might be better for Sri Lanka and us if blogging began to enter (and hopefully divert) the mainstream. I also see a lot of village bloggers appear and drop off and I know that they need more support. To that end I drafted a small business plan and applied for a grant from the Ashoka Changemakers Group for their Power Of Us competition. It’s an open format so if you A) support the idea B) have suggestions or C) want to destroy it please take a moment to register on that site and comment.

As a preliminary note, I’d say it’s safe to assume that this won’t pan and status quo will remain. It’s just a link Sanjana sent me and I figured it’s worth a shot. I’m also reluctant dealing with money at all, mainly because of what Biggie said. I mean, I’ve seen money mess up friendships and communities before and I really don’t want that to happen to Kottu. However, I also think Kottu could use a stimulus to grow, because the growth has stabilized over the years. But I dunno. Welcome anybody’s thoughts on this.

The amount of money in question is $25,000 USD I think. If I read the stuff correctly. That isn’t much in funding terms, but it’d be a pretty good stimulus for the blogging community here. Right now I personally spend about $500 a year on the server, though my ideal setup would be at least double that. I also keep a bunch of other stuff on there, but Kottu is by far the most resource intensive. I can fund this indefinitely and I’m OK with that. There are four specific investments, however, which I think would be a much needed stimulus for the community. My hope is that, in turn, the community can be a much needed stimulus for Sri Lankan media, and Sri Lanka in general.

Technology

As Kottu gets bigger it needs to ‘read’ more feeds. The code is a mess I hacked together and it’s not very efficient. I don’t really have the PHP chops to optimize it, so when it started to crash I just bought more and more memory for the server. This works for now, but it’s obviously not the ideal situation. I’d like to hire someone to optimize the code, make it comply to Web Standards, be more mobile friendly, and hopefully package it as something open source that anyone could deploy.

Events

The last Meetup was like two years ago. I paid like $150 out of pocket and it was actually quite fruitful. It was a different community entirely, but it was fun. However, I’m naturally a bit anxious and events really stress me out. I’ve also come to understand the proper events actually require a bit of planning and money. So I’ve written a fairly big budget for one or two really good events. I say that few because I’ve seen what corporate level events cost, and I think it’s important to do it right. Perhaps at a time when everyone is in the country. There’s also the issue of including rural bloggers, which I think’d be an added cost in terms of some transport and lodging support. I don’t know what form this would take, maybe a Bloggy Awards or just a casual meetup. There’s a slot for a Project Manager in there cause I honestly want as little to do with it as possible.

Education

There a lot of rural bloggers who send requests to join Kottu, but very very few make more than one or two posts. In my interactions with them they’ve said that they see blogging as a way to learn English, but they’re obviously not getting that type of support from Kottu. Yet they’re putting themselves out there, they do have really good stories, and I think it’d be good all around to meet them halfway. I’ve had this idea of teaching English through blogs (as in, one teacher blogger giving assignments, students blogging them, corrections via comments). However, this requires organization and funding beyond my ken. This is something I’d like Kottu to do.

Marketing

Another idea brewing (or stewing, moreso) has been connecting bloggers to the mainstream media. There’s multiple angles, but advertising is the most simple. Just to get the idea and some of the content out there in the print and electronic media that people know. As well as advertising online to get direct clicks and eyeballs. Because there is a lot of really great content on Kottu that I think people should know about. I mean, I used to dominate the top five default, but now I really have to work for it, because there is competition. And that’s good to see, and more people should see.

Anyways, I’d prefer to include the doc and all the details here, but I suspect chances of getting the award would increase if the comments and discussion happened there. The site itself is kinda Web 1.0 manky and you have to register to comment at all (painful) but I’d really appreciate if any positive/negative comments and suggestions were directed there.

The stuff that I think needs public airing are all money related. I’ve included amounts for Program Management of the whole thing, Project Management of components and goods and services from various suppliers. This is me and various people I know and work with so there’s obviously issues here that everyone needs to look at. I believe in paying people for work, including myself. More out of practicality than anything. In my experience setting deliverables and fair compensation results in stuff actually getting done, on time. If you have issues with me or any of the people I’ve mentioned as the team, please air them. I think me and this team can get the job done, but people on Kottu can choose their own destiny. I’m open to changing/scrapping/rerouting the whole thing, because I have to be.

Please visit www.changemakers.com/en-us/node/15204 to post comments. It’s a pain to register, but the comments there make a difference in the final evaluation.

RSS feed | Trackback URI

13 Comments »

Comment by Dee
2009-01-07 09:48:28

ooo Bloggy Awards ! that’s an awesome idea :D… I’m definitely up to helping you Indz.. :) gonna check out the link now…

 
Comment by The Whackster
2009-01-07 11:10:12

dude i tried logging in several times. appears to be something the matter, will keep at it. love the teaching english idea and the marketing angle. i’ll help out too. cheers

 
Comment by Jerry
2009-01-07 11:48:18

I work for an event management company. But planning an “event” would mean making it big. You’d have to go the bloggy awards way or make it a really extravagant casual affair, if such a thing exists. Of course, the awards thing will cost much more, at least a few hundred k’s. Best bet for a meet is privately hiring a location and just get everyone to show up. If need be, a bunch of people can organise some speakers or something.

Re the cost of running the site, why not run adverts on kottu itself to generate revenue on a per click basis? Surely it has enough traffic to make up the amount needed?

Comment by Jerry
2009-01-07 12:04:15

…But looking at the numbers involved, that seems like a bad idea… That many people need managing. :)

 
 
Comment by Jerry
2009-01-07 11:49:41

And I’m not sure if it’s just me, but the site throws up an Internal Server Error 500 occasionally. Even right now :s

Comment by indi
2009-01-07 13:42:50

That’s cause, as mentioned, the technology needs upgrading. Saw it went 500 and rebooted and added more memory, but that can only go on so long

 
 
Comment by Harsha G.
2009-01-07 12:51:35

Have you thought about having a fund raiser .. a small one among friends and family to start with to test the water and then graduate to bigger and better things?

 
Comment by indi
2009-01-07 14:04:01

@Harsha

That’s an event, stresses me out.

This money is there, just applying for it. Don’t think Kottu will get it, but worth a shot

 
Comment by cerno
2009-01-08 00:17:55

Question for indi regarding the kottu.org business plan: What would your role as “Program Manager” involve?

I just hope it won’t mean you have to surrender the ownership of kottu.org to committee or something. You’ve sort of had a Linus Torvalds like role in kottu so far which I think has been a strength in keeping it going for so long.

An idea for Kottu 2.0:
Set a time frame for dropping inactive nodes. Say 3 weeks of no posts and they get a “drop notice”. 1 month without a posting they get dropped from kottu and have to manually reapply.

Comment by indi
2009-01-08 08:28:23

Guess the same stuff as now. I don’t think Kottu will devolve to committee yet just cause enough people aren’t interested in actually managing it. Linus owns the Linux trademark, and I technically own the kottu.org domain name. I’m not that interested in ‘owning’ it though, I have indi.ca. I am interested in it existing, and being cool.

That’s a good idea. Could code it such that it sends an automated email and automatically clears inactive blogs. Right now I just get frustrated one day and manually go through every single blog on there, checking dates. A lot of stuff could be automated.

Comment by cerno
2009-01-08 14:24:41

Another items for the “things to automate” list I guess. I hope you get this grant. Getting Vessess to deal with the code will give you the time and sanity to deal with more “executive” stuff ;) And yes, please don’t hand it kottu.org over to a committee.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
 
 
Comment by Yo
2009-01-09 20:53:46

Tried to comment at ChangeMakers, didn’t work for some reason.

I think your ideas for Kottu are great, Indi.

The tech could be better and I agree that getting a professional web-standards company to rebuild it is the way forward.

As for events, how about getting sponsorship for a Bloggy Awards event? Surely not out of the realms of possibility? The hard part would of course be getting sponsor(s) interested, but I think the time is right for Kottu to be seen as attractive to advertising companies. You should of course steer clear of placing ads on Kottu itself, but I think a sponsored awards event and/or meetup is viable? The sponsor could publicise the event, give away promotional items and prizes on the day, and get significant coverage across the Kottu blogosphere.

The education idea is great. I’m not clear on exactly what form it would take, but I would love to help someone to improve their English by mentoring their blog. I could commit a few hours a week to this, and I’m sure many others would too.

On marketing, I’ve also thought for a long time that much of the content on Kottu deserves to be in print, to be put out there. Sorry to say but I find that most of the print media just says the same thing, but Kottu is a place where I can depend on reading diverse and opposing opinions, which I think is the main attraction. I know it’s work, but if you can again approach this by finding a sponsor, I think that there would be a decent readership who would buy a monthly/weekly Kottu magazine. I’d love my (non-IT-savvy) family to be able to read the stuff on Kottu – it’s a broader view of what people are saying about what’s in the news.

Best of luck with the great plans, if I can help I will.

 
Comment by indi
2009-01-09 21:12:43

Fuck it, comment here. That site is mara kludgy.

I could probably get it sponsored without too much trouble. Someone offered to sponsor the last one. The issue is that banners and stuff are tacky and commercial.

 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

email indi AT indi.ca.


Recent Comments


The English Speaking Elite:
  • Mahinda: This is sort of a forum, isn't it? What I mean is that Indi posts something, everyone has a quick read, then starts using this space to air their own views and spread their own message or start their own little (quite often completely unrelated) arguments or whatever... Its got an organic quality, which I think is quite nice......
  • The way of the Dodo: I think we should take some of this stuff and create a forum. That allows for better discussion and more mature dialog. What do you guys think...
  • Mahinda: Just curious... Didn't mean to offend....
Much More Mahinda:
  • Mahinda: Lousy, uninteresting comeback with only mild entertainment value. Where's the wit? Where's the logic/justification to the comment? I'm disappointed in you......
  • David Blacker: Mahinda, I doubt you'd make a good bench press, never mind a press sec....
  • Mahinda: Machang Blacker! Where have you been??! Were you busy washing your hair or something? Oh sorry - you don't have hair, no? So why the offensive attitude? Don't you think I'd make a good press sec? ;)...
The Final Cross:
  • Mahinda: Flyovers, if effectively used, are an excellent method of improving the flow of traffic and congestion. Since you guys don't think the ones that have been built work terribly well towards that objective, lets just blame Mahinda and the Government for this and move on :) Ok. That was just a little joke, but on a serious note, I think development should be well thought out and also implemented in the most cost effective manner. Which...
  • Anon: To add to what Dodo say, before the fly-over there was stop-go traffic at the Dehiwala junction. After the flyover there is a continuous, but slow flow of traffic. Although I use that road only rarely in my limited experience the length of the queue and the time taken to travel is no better after the flyover, and may be slightly worse. Moving the bus stand would be an improvement at Dehiwala, think Nugegoda is somewhat more...
  • Anon: Thanks Shammi, there was a very good interview in the Nation a few years back that opened my eyes to him. Think he did a fair job at the port and according to reports did not take a large "grant" that was in the offing. Agree with Dodo that Mangala's chances of getting elected at the moment look pretty slip....

Related Posts


Kottu 0.3

I redid kottu.org from scratch this weekend. The old version was designed as a personal feedreader, and it was growing hard to customize for the job it needed to do. I would like to say that Gregarius is the best personal feedreader I've seen, and Marco is very cool. That version is still available at kottu.org/feed/. The new version is running on Wordpress, which I use for everything, including this blog.

What’s Wrong With Kottu

In a word, me. In university I basically failed out of the Computer Science portion of my degrees because, despite flashes of ingenuity, I can't code for shit. Everything I've ever written tends to melt servers under high volumes, and this happens to Kottu, basically cyclically. The problem is that Kottu has gotten huge. I don't know how many feeds are on there, it's definitely over 200. In one update (from scratch) Kottu pulls in

Kottu Print, Demo

I talked about this ages ago. Ran into some money issues with an insert but we're doing a test run tomorrow in one of the sections of the Sunday Leader. The 'Review' section I believe, there's a sample of Kottu in the middle. Not hyping it too much, the images may be upside down and the thing may be on fire, I dunno. Things often get befuddled on the way to the printer. This is

Kottu 0.4

I went in to change one thing but ended up redesigning Kottu. The more whitespace tagline is fully lifted from the inestimable Jon Hicks. I'll take it down soon, just for funny. I like his design sense and I feel better now that the artificial box is gone. Besides that I tried to clean up and minimize as much as possible, so as to minimize the brain hurt. Also deleted

On Kottu’s Security

Ok, er, wow. Now Nibras Bawa is sending out mails threatening to hack Kottu. Is it possible to break Kottu? Yes, I do it all the time. However, it's simply impossible to destroy peoples content as Bawa claims. Kottu is an aggregator. It doesn't host any content at all. I've completely crashed Kottu and been able to reconstitute it in 10 minutes. It's basically Wordpress plus a few plugins and a blogroll. The beauty of