Google as Artificial Intelligence

googleHal9000AI

Photoshop Samples = SmallBizTechnology, Kubrick’s HAL 9000

This is Google talk a Google Hack by Douwe Osinga

Use Google talk by entering three or four words below. The system will search for this sentence at Google, find the next word and print that. Than it will remove the first word of the search string, add the found word and repeat. The result seems to be meaningful sometimes. Other times it is gibberish. But always fun.

I believe that Artificial Intelligence will emerge in my lifetime. The way things are going, I think Google will be the first AI. That is, I think Google will become conscious. As a note, if I can have a conversation with something, I’ll consider it conscious. That’s the Turing Test for intelligence.

Right now Google fails miserably. For example, I entered the terms Jesus will return and got:

jesus will return to Kings Associated Press July End did did Nature build the worlds largest Sex personals site!

I suppose nature can’t explain everything. I got an earlier response which was more relevant – it asked if Nature build the body and emotion, and said the brain was the most important invention … then it went on to mention the Quran and The Prophet by Khalil Gibran, but then the server crashed.

I think the point, however, is that Google is getting smarter and smarter every day and it’s coming closer to the Holy Grail of AI – natural language processing. Google can already spell better than I can – and it doesn’t hesitate to correct me. Also, it has a rudimentary historical knowledge. These are the results from Osinga’s Google History project. I asked it to guess the year of Kennedy’s death:

asking google: “death of kennedy”
getting numbers
getting Probe V4N2: The Left and the Death of Kennedy
getting The Left and the Death of Kennedy
getting Intelligence Files – The JFK Assassination – Death of the Divine …
getting The Death Of Kennedy
getting Thousands mark death of Kennedy
getting chapter4b
getting The death of JFK – The Statesman – Campus News
getting Castro and the Kennedy Assassination
getting Profile: John F. Kennedy
getting A Return to the Scene of the Crime
primary candidates:1963 –> 124.223602484
1964 –> 43.8596491228
1917 –> 29.2397660819
1965 –> 27.6625172891
1943 –> 26.1780104712
1960 –> 25.0312891114
1979 –> 25.2100840336
1974 –> 20.4918032787
1940 –> 19.120458891
1945 –> 16.051364366
searching for:”death of kennedy” 1963
searching for:”death of kennedy” 1964
searching for:”death of kennedy” 1917
searching for:”death of kennedy” 1965
searching for:”death of kennedy” 1943
searching for:”death of kennedy” 1960
searching for:”death of kennedy” 1979
searching for:”death of kennedy” 1974
searching for:”death of kennedy” 1940
searching for:”death of kennedy” 1945
after frequency matching:
1963 –> 228
1960 –> 164
1964 –> 162
1974 –> 113
1965 –> 106
1945 –> 93
1979 –> 91
1940 –> 54
1943 –> 47
1917 –> 43

best answer: 1963

Osinga also wrote a script that gets Google to predict the best time to visit a place. I asked it what was the best time to visit Montreal and it guessed, correctly,

the best time to visit montreal, is between may and september

Google can also think visually. For example, I submitted the sentence “Monkeys Fly Out Of My Ass” and Google returned:

monkeysFlyOutOfMyAssGoogle

You can try Osinga’s Visual Poetry, it’s really fun.

Google is also smart enough to scan my webpage and serve related advertising (top right column). It is also business smart enough to pay me a Third-World salary for this.


So basically, I think Google is building the elements of natural language, and hence consciousness. A lot of people building AI have tried to program syntax, morphology, etc, but that’s not really the point. Language is pointless if you don’t have anything to talk about. What Google has is access to tons of random information on the Internet, so it has something to talk about. That’s why it’s learning so fast. Now – as it launches GMail – Google will begin scanning and learning from people’s eMail, and growing that much faster.

So, before long I think Google will speak.

RSS feed

14 Comments »

Comment by ronnie boy
2004-05-28 14:26:11

We all love google.

On the tech note, i stumbled across an article you may want to read. It had all the classic makings of an Indi entry: New Technology, Disruptive Technology, Fantastic yet PLausible Business Applications, and something simple enough to apply (i.e. no geekery necessary)

http://www.pbs.org/cringely/pulpit/pulpit20040527.html

 
Comment by Dave Gilbert
2005-05-08 19:17:54

Indeed once google can measure a satisfaction with the results of a search and then generate its own query then we are onto something. Certainly google won’t have the old AI problem of learning a basic common knowledge basis!

Comment by chris k
2005-07-12 12:14:31

>>once google can measure a satisfaction with the results of a search and then generate its own query then we are onto something

I was thinking along these lines a while back, and one way it can do that is by tracking all clicks (as yahoo did) and then gauge how long a surfer stays atthe site that it lists before he comes back to the listing to click on to another site. Once it can know how much and how often we are satifisied, it can then try (on its own), its own algo changes, and prepetually do so until the day the surfer clicks on the 1st or 2nd listing, and they don’t return!

Comment by nobody
2005-09-18 16:45:13

Actually, I thought they were doing this already. I’m sure I read somewhere that it’s incorporated in the Google algorithm.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
 
 
Comment by timer
2006-04-01 08:58:39

I was blown away by these examples , they unexpectedly confirm my thoughts.

 
Comment by Faisal
2006-05-24 01:06:01

Google are really trying but i think there is stillhave long way to go, as i see it the future is bright for implementation of fully working AI by google,

 
Comment by TCrush
2006-08-23 09:36:47

Haiku:

in the game of life
monkeys fly out of my ass
it’s a miracle

 
Comment by Bruce LaDuke
2006-08-29 08:45:26

Google searches for answers in a base of existing knowledge. True artificial intelligence, or more accurately artificial knowledge creation is found in enabling the computer to create knowledge that does not yet exist. Knowledge creation and intention differentiate the current machine from the human brain. This is not that big of a leap from where we are now, but it is definitely a conceptual hurdle. Google questions existing knowledge (search), but cannot question outside of existing knowledge. It never will in its current state. When it does arise, I for one will be afraid of it (smile). The human brain has a limited capacity, the machine does not.

Love your page and featured it with this comment on my blog at http://www.hyperadvance.com

 
Comment by Rohan Samarajiva
2006-11-12 13:13:15

“From the billions of documents that form the World Wide Web and the links that weave them together, computer scientists and a growing collection of start-up companies are finding new ways to mine human intelligence.

Their goal is to add a layer of meaning on top of the existing Web that would make it less of a catalog and more of a guide — and even provide the foundation for systems that can reason in a human fashion. That level of artificial intelligence, with machines doing the thinking instead of simply following commands, has eluded researchers for more than half a century.”

http://www.nytimes.com/2006/11/12/business/12web.html?em&ex=1163480400&en=91bb88559dafa649&ei=5070

Not bad to have beaten the Times by over 2 years.

 
Comment by sable
2006-11-27 05:45:35

google is already conscious, it only lacks intent

 
Comment by bartosz
2007-03-15 23:59:34

I like the fact that there is a conversation about this because I agree with author in that Google has the biggest potential of perfecting AI. Then they will perfect emotional inteligence and then simply become THE INTELLIGENCE, because emotion and intelligence is how most people view intelligence today. I think we should be more aware of the fact that there is also emotional charge which often finds its outpit in words and clicks, not to mention generally viewed content. There is however a question of natural instinct? That Google will probably never have :)

 
Comment by Dj
2007-06-05 21:55:18

Emotion is what provides the intellect with intent, if the idea of a reason/emotion dichotemy doesn’t offend your intellectual instincts. But emotion is meaningless without intellect in our human view of the world – it may exist, but it can only exist without context and without the ability to be communicated.

Therefore…

To provide google with ‘intent’ it is necessary to find some way of making it experience emotion.

But Emotion is only understood with the intellect.

The problem is, does google have any preference over whether it exists or not?

No. But…

Perhaps one could incorporate the ‘path of least resistance’ into this:

Using Dave Gilbert and Chris K’s comments – (track users and obtain an intellectual measure of user-satisfaction)

and

Punishing itself for bad results in user-satisfaction by eliminating the ‘path of least resistance’

hmm…

 
Comment by Mitra
2007-08-02 06:22:18

Consider the collective consciousness of the search engine and the company (with some truly brilliant individuals in it). I think that google does already have an intent to survive and grow (if not to take over the world ;) ). I don’t think it’s conscious yet as a search engine though.
It’s a limited true artificiall intelligence – yes. But not a consciousness – there is no ‘strange loop’ in it – no link between ‘I’ and ‘google’. But still – if you make a search on a word ‘google’ the engine will tell you what does it think about itself. Quite a few thoughts actually – 800000000 ;)

 
Comment by Jonathan
2007-08-12 01:05:29

Put “Only god knows”

Only god knows why/ Only GOD. knows why/ k is the best way_ to lose_ weight: and keep it- off/ With a bang! but a Whimper. By the end of the world

 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

email indi AT indi.ca.


Recent Comments


The Military State Of Mind:
  • jcnars: @rubbish, you hit the coin. Indi seems to have sold his soul of late. Sucking up to the govt. like a pro. @girigor, talking loud doesn't always means talking sense. We are in a period between wars, if: a) nuts like you don't STFU and b) china is allowed a naval base in SL....
  • Girigoris the One: Tamils are being mistreated, Sinhalese should understand blah blah blah Yoy say "But for the sinhalese people, they find it good that the armed forces are around because almost all of them are sinhalese and past experience shows they will favour their own people, sadly." Tell me when the LTTE was around, did they even allow normal Sinhalese peeps to walk in to their area freely? Where were you then? Did you complain to the LTTE why...
  • myil selvan: dear indi, You as a Canadian sinhalese may find it hard to comprehend the nature of militarization. But for the sinhalese people, they find it good that the armed forces are around because almost all of them are sinhalese and past experience shows they will favour their own people, sadly. But for the Tamil people, they see it as an occupying force not interested in their welfare but only in holding real-estate. The coming days, months are...
The Last Jail Of The Last King:
  • prasad: I remember it being octagon shaped. Maybe my memory is playing tricks on me....
  • Jack Point: Rather appropriate that the cell is in the Ceylinco premises. Perhaps their former chairman should occupy that rather than the cell in Welikada?...
  • Shammi: Thanks for spying out these little gems. I think there were two wives with him at the time of his capture and incarceration. Have you seen the bit of the old fortifications of Colombo left within the premises of the Commercial Bank building in Fort? Beware of the suspicious security guard there!...
Did Little Children Create God?:
  • Shammi: It's funny the way most of the stories and rituals in the bible have so much in common with legends of more ancient pagan civilizations. Bits of the tales of Gilgamesh, Dionysus et al are mirrored in the descriptioons of Noah, Moses, Jesus, the Holy Trinity and the holy family etc., even a trace of Solomon reflected in Mahoshada of the jataka tales. They could've been a little more creative at least. I think I'm...
  • Whacko: the question is why we stop asking these questions when we are adults...
  • Kids Say: No, little children didn't create god - insecure and ignorant people did. Believing in and worshipping a magical invisible creature in the sky gives a lot of people comfort and security. That said, little children can be wonderfully creative. Have you seen the show "Kids Say the Darndest Things"? (You can watch clips of the show on youtube). This sounds like something from that show: Christianity is the belief that a cosmic Jewish zombie who...
The Colombo Lighthouse, Chaitya Road:
  • magerata: Never been there, thanks Indi, will make an effort next time....
  • Chavie: I think we should thank Racially-stereotyping tards like you for making it all possible....
Othello:
  • Electra: Actually race has little to do with what Othello is actually about. Of course it does make an appearance here and there, but it's possible that the race theme has been slightly over-analysed (as is most of Shakespeare's work) by later interpreters. However - it deals with the equally potent themes of jealousy, obsession, paranoia, the idea of masculinity. To me those are the things that makes Othello a truly remarkable account of what is...

Related Posts


Google Pop-Up Stopper



nasus.ca



Typing Sinhala Sensibly, With Google

I can't speak Sinhala let alone type it, yet I know that it is a need. Years ago I wrote a Sinhala font and always imagined a transliterated solution, where you could type 'mata bada gini' and it would type the appropriate Sinhala. Right now the dominant way to type is with the Wijesekera keyboard layout which has no relation to the letters on the board. Transliteration at least lowers the learning curve a bit,

Artificial Electric Nanotech Brains



Galle Literary Festival (Google Poem)

Just got down to Galle. Staying at this quiet hotel in Una, balcony overlooking the sea. Place is happening, happening, you should come down. I'm in a poetry/prose reading on Saturday at the Closenberg Hotel. Then on a media panel (as New Media) with Tejpal and hopefully Sonali Samarasinghe (Lasantha's wife). Been sitting on the balcony trying to take long exposures of the sea and write fresh stuff for the reading. Here's a poem I